Skip to main content

Voting record · October Term 2023 (2023–2024)

How Elena Kagan voted in the October Term 2023 (2023–2024)

Associate Justice60 tracked case votesAll terms

October Term 2023 (2023–2024)

Term at a glance

Majority
39
Concurrence
3
Dissent
18
Recusal
0
Authored
13

Case by case

Every tracked vote

How Justice Elena Kagan voted in each tracked Supreme Court case
CaseVoteOpinionDecidedTerm
Corner Post, Inc. v. Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve SystemDocket 22-1008DissentJuly 1, 20242023
Moody v. NetChoiceDocket 22-277MajorityAuthoredJuly 1, 20242023
NetChoice, LLC v. PaxtonDocket 22-555MajorityAuthoredJuly 1, 20242023
Trump v. United StatesDocket 23-939DissentJuly 1, 20242023
Relentless, Inc. v. Dept. of CommerceDocket 22-1219DissentAuthoredJune 28, 20242023
Loper Bright Enterprises v. RaimondoDocket 22-451DissentAuthoredJune 28, 20242023
City of Grants Pass v. JohnsonDocket 23-175DissentJune 28, 20242023
Fischer v. United StatesDocket 23-5572DissentJune 28, 20242023
SEC v. JarkesyDocket 22-859DissentJune 27, 20242023
Harrington v. Purdue Pharma L.P.Docket 23-124DissentJune 27, 20242023
Moyle v. United StatesDocket 23-726ConcurrenceAuthoredJune 27, 20242023
Ohio, et al., Applicants v. Environmental Protection Agency, et al.Docket 23A349DissentJune 27, 20242023
Snyder v. United StatesDocket 23-108DissentJune 26, 20242023
Vivek H. Murthy, Surgeon General, et al., Petitioners v. Missouri, et al.Docket 23-411MajorityJune 26, 20242023
Smith v. ArizonaDocket 22-899MajorityAuthoredJune 21, 20242023
United States v. RahimiDocket 22-915MajorityJune 21, 20242023
Department of State, et al., Petitioners v. Sandra Muñoz, et al.Docket 23-334DissentJune 21, 20242023
Erlinger v. United StatesDocket 23-370MajorityJune 21, 20242023
Gonzalez v. TrevinoDocket 22-1025MajorityJune 20, 20242023
Moore v. United StatesDocket 22-800MajorityJune 20, 20242023
Diaz v. United StatesDocket 23-14DissentJune 20, 20242023
Chiaverini v. City of Napoleon, OhioDocket 23-50MajorityAuthoredJune 20, 20242023
United States Trustee v. John Q. Hammons Fall 2006, LLCDocket 22-1238MajorityJune 14, 20242023
Campos-Chaves v. GarlandDocket 22-674DissentJune 14, 20242023
Merrick B. Garland, Attorney General, et al., Petitioners v. Michael CargillDocket 22-976DissentJune 14, 20242023
Vidal v. ElsterDocket 22-704MajorityJune 13, 20242023
FDA v. Alliance for Hippocratic MedicineDocket 23-235MajorityJune 13, 20242023
Starbucks Corp. v. McKinneyDocket 23-367MajorityJune 13, 20242023
Truck Insurance Exchange, Petitioner v. Kaiser Gypsum Company, Inc., et al.Docket 22-1079MajorityJune 6, 20242023
Connelly v. United StatesDocket 23-146MajorityJune 6, 20242023
Becerra v. San Carlos Apache TribeDocket 23-250MajorityJune 6, 20242023
Cantero v. Bank of America, N. A.Docket 22-529MajorityMay 30, 20242023
NRA v. VulloDocket 22-842MajorityMay 30, 20242023
Thornell v. JonesDocket 22-982DissentMay 30, 20242023
Justin Rashaad Brown, Petitioner v. United StatesDocket 22-6389DissentMay 23, 20242023
Alexander v. South Carolina State Conference of the NAACPDocket 22-807DissentAuthoredMay 23, 20242023
Coinbase v. SuskiDocket 23-3MajorityMay 23, 20242023
Smith v. SpizzirriDocket 22-1218MajorityMay 16, 20242023
Consumer Financial Protection Bureau v. Community Financial Services Assn. of America, Ltd.Docket 22-448ConcurrenceAuthoredMay 16, 20242023
Harrow v. Department of DefenseDocket 23-21MajorityAuthoredMay 16, 20242023
Warner Chappell Music, Inc. v. NealyDocket 22-1078MajorityAuthoredMay 9, 20242023
Culley v. MarshallDocket 22-585DissentMay 9, 20242023
Muldrow v. City of St. LouisDocket 22-193MajorityAuthoredApril 17, 20242023
McIntosh v. United StatesDocket 22-7386MajorityApril 17, 20242023
Rudisill v. McDonoughDocket 22-888MajorityApril 16, 20242023
DeVillier v. TexasDocket 22-913MajorityApril 16, 20242023
Sheetz v. El Dorado CountyDocket 22-1074MajorityApril 12, 20242023
Macquarie Infrastructure Corp. v. Moab Partners, L. P.Docket 22-1165MajorityApril 12, 20242023
Bissonnette v. LePage Bakeries Park St., LLCDocket 23-51MajorityApril 12, 20242023
FBI v. FikreDocket 22-1178MajorityMarch 19, 20242023
Situ Kamu Wilkinson, Petitioner v. Merrick B. Garland, Attorney GeneralDocket 22-666MajorityMarch 19, 20242023
O'Connor-Ratcliff v. GarnierDocket 22-324MajorityMarch 15, 20242023
Pulsifer v. United StatesDocket 22-340MajorityAuthoredMarch 15, 20242023
Lindke v. FreedDocket 22-611MajorityMarch 15, 20242023
Trump v. AndersonDocket 23-719ConcurrenceMarch 4, 20242023
Great Lakes Ins. SE v. Raiders Retreat Realty Co.Docket 22-500MajorityFebruary 21, 20242023
McElrath v. GeorgiaDocket 22-721MajorityFebruary 21, 20242023
Murray v. UBS Securities, LLCDocket 22-660MajorityFebruary 8, 20242023
Department of Agriculture Rural Development Rural Housing Service v. KirtzDocket 22-846MajorityFebruary 8, 20242023
Acheson Hotels, LLC v. LauferDocket 22-429MajorityDecember 5, 20232023

October Term 2023 (2023–2024)

Agreement with other justices

Share of decided cases this term in which Justice Elena Kagan voted on the same side of the judgment as each other justice
JusticeAgreementCases together
Sonia Sotomayor97%58 of 60
Ketanji Brown Jackson90%53 of 59
Amy Coney Barrett70%42 of 60
John G. Roberts, Jr.70%42 of 60
Brett M. Kavanaugh68%41 of 60
Neil Gorsuch62%37 of 60
Samuel A. Alito, Jr.54%32 of 59
Clarence Thomas52%31 of 60

Methodology

  • Vote records come from Oyez and cover publicly tracked merits cases; recusals are listed but excluded from agreement rates.
  • Two justices "agree" in a case when they land on the same side of the judgment — voting with the majority (including concurrences) or in dissent together. A case counts toward agreement rates only when at least 8 substantive votes are on record.

Justice profile · Term statistics · How this site is generated