Voting record
How Elena Kagan voted in the October Term 2016 (2016–2017)
Associate Justice27 tracked case votes
Term at a glance
- Majority
- 25
- Concurrence
- 0
- Dissent
- 2
- Recusal
- 0
- Authored
- 5
- Majority25
- Concurrence0
- Dissent2
- Recused0
Every tracked vote
Religious groups and public aidTrinity Lutheran Church of Columbia, Inc. v. ComerDecided Vote Majority15-577Combining neighboring propertiesMurr v. WisconsinDecided Vote Majority15-214Where federal workers appealPerry v. Merit Systems Protection Bd.Decided Vote Majority16-399Withheld evidence in criminal trialsTurner v. United StatesDecided Vote DissentAuthored15-1503Where companies can be suedBristol-Myers Squibb Co. v. Superior Court of Cal., San Francisco Cty.Decided Vote Majority16-466SEC deadline to recover profitsKokesh v. SECDecided Vote Majority16-529Where companies can be suedBNSF R. Co. v. TyrrellDecided Vote Majority16-405Race in congressional mapsCooper v. HarrisDecided Vote MajorityAuthored15-1262Power of attorney arbitrationKindred Nursing Centers, L. P. v. ClarkDecided Vote MajorityAuthored16-32Old debts in bankruptcyMidland Funding, LLC v. JohnsonDecided Vote Dissent16-348Tribal immunity for personal damagesLewis v. ClarkeDecided Vote Majority15-1500Refunds after overturned convictionsNelson v. ColoradoDecided Vote Majority15-1256Appeals of delayed restitutionManrique v. United StatesDecided Vote Majority15-7250Legal fees for misconductGoodyear Tire & Rubber Co. v. HaegerDecided Vote MajorityAuthored15-1406Claims on injury settlementsCoventry Health Care of Mo., Inc. v. NevilsDecided Vote Majority16-149Appeals of agency subpoenasMcLane Co. v. EEOCDecided Vote Majority15-1248Considering consecutive gun sentencesDean v. United StatesDecided Vote Majority15-9260Bankruptcy payment prioritiesCzyzewski v. Jevic Holding Corp.Decided Vote Majority15-649Progress in special educationEndrew F. v. Douglas County School Dist. RE–1Decided Vote Majority15-827Manuel v. JolietDecided Vote MajorityAuthored14-9496Racial bias in jury deliberationsPena-Rodriguez v. ColoradoDecided Vote Majority15-606Race in voting districtsBethune-Hill v. Virginia State Bd. of ElectionsDecided Vote Majority15-680Warnings before police shootingsRay White v. Daniel T. Pauly, as Personal Representative of the Estate of Samuel PaulyDecided Vote Majority16-67Secrecy in fraud lawsuitsState Farm Fire & Casualty Co. v. United States ex rel. RigsbyDecided Vote Majority15-513Insider trading and family tiesSalman v. United StatesDecided Vote Majority15-628When acquittals block retrialsBravo-Fernandez v. United StatesDecided Vote Majority15-537Victim impact testimonyShaun Michael Bosse v. OklahomaDecided Vote Majority15-9173
Agreement with other justices
| Justice | Agreement | Cases together |
|---|---|---|
| Stephen G. Breyer | 93% | 25 of 27 |
| Anthony M. Kennedy | 89% | 24 of 27 |
| Ruth Bader Ginsburg | 89% | 24 of 27 |
| John G. Roberts, Jr. | 81% | 22 of 27 |
| Sonia Sotomayor | 81% | 22 of 27 |
| Neil Gorsuch | 80% | 4 of 5 |
| Samuel A. Alito, Jr. | 74% | 20 of 27 |
| Clarence Thomas | 67% | 18 of 27 |
Methodology
Two justices agree in a case when they land on the same side of the judgment: voting with the majority, including concurrences, or in dissent together.
Vote records come from Oyez. A case counts only when at least 8 substantive votes are on record, so partial data can understate coverage but a vote is never invented. Recusals are listed but left out of agreement rates.