Skip to main content

Voting record

How Samuel A. Alito, Jr. voted in the October Term 2013 (2013–2014)

Associate Justice61 tracked case votes

Term at a glance

October Term 2013 (2013–2014)

Majority
46
Concurrence
6
Dissent
8
Recusal
1
Authored
17
  • Majority46
  • Concurrence6
  • Dissent8
  • Recused1
On the winning side of the judgment in 87% of 60 participating votes.

Every tracked vote

Religious objections to birth controlSylvia Burwell, Secretary of Health and Human Services v. Hobby Lobby Stores, Inc.Decided Vote MajorityAuthored13-354Abortion clinic buffer zonesEleanor McCullen v. Martha Coakley, Attorney General of MassachusettsDecided Vote ConcurrenceAuthored12-1168President's recess appointmentsNational Labor Relations Board v. Noel CanningDecided Vote Concurrence12-1281Company stock in retirement plansFifth Third Bancorp v. John DudenhoefferDecided Vote Majority12-751Warrants for phone searchesDavid Leon Riley v. CaliforniaDecided Vote ConcurrenceAuthored13-132Copyright for TV streamingAmerican Broadcasting Companies, Inc. v. Aereo, Inc., fka Bamboom Labs, Inc.Decided Vote Dissent13-461Permits for greenhouse gas emissionsUtility Air Regulatory Group v. Environmental Protection AgencyDecided Vote MajorityAuthored12-1146Stock fraud class actionsHalliburton Co. v. Erica P. John Fund, Inc., fka Archdiocese of Milwaukee Supporting Fund, Inc.Decided Vote Concurrence13-317Computer software patentsAlice Corporation Pty. Ltd. v. CLS Bank InternationalDecided Vote Majority13-298Hearings on IRS summonsesUnited States v. Michael ClarkeDecided Vote Majority13-301Public employee free speechEdward R. Lane v. Steve Franks, in His Individual Capacity, and Susan Burrow, in Her Official Capacity as Acting President of Central Alabama Community CollegeDecided Vote Majority13-483Gun buyer identityBruce James Abramski, Jr. v. United StatesDecided Vote Dissent12-1493Subpoenas for foreign assetsRepublic of Argentina v. NML Capital, Ltd.Decided Vote Majority12-842Laws against false political speechSusan B. Anthony List v. Steven DriehausDecided Vote Majority13-193False advertising on food labelsPOM Wonderful LLC v. The Coca-Cola CompanyDecided Vote Majority12-761Inherited IRAs in bankruptcyBrandon C. Clark, et ux. v. William J. Rameker, TrusteeDecided Vote Majority13-299Bankruptcy judges' authorityExecutive Benefits Insurance Agency v. Peter H. Arkison, Chapter 7 Trustee of the Estate of Bellingham Insurance Agency, Inc.Decided Vote Majority12-1200Children aging out of visasLori Scialabba, Acting Director, United States Citizenship and Immigration Services v. Rosalina Cuellar de OsorioDecided Vote DissentAuthored12-930Pollution lawsuit deadlinesCTS Corporation v. Peter WaldburgerDecided Vote Majority13-339Federal power over local poisoningCarol Anne Bond v. United StatesDecided Vote ConcurrenceAuthored12-158Encouraging patent infringementLimelight Networks, Inc. v. Akamai Technologies, Inc.Decided Vote MajorityAuthored12-786Clear patent claimsNautilus, Inc. v. Biosig Instruments, Inc.Decided Vote Majority13-369Death penalty disability rulesFreddie Lee Hall v. FloridaDecided Vote DissentAuthored12-10882Police shootings during car chasesOfficer Vance Plumhoff v. Whitne Rickard, a Minor Child, Individually, and as Surviving Daughter of Donald Rickard, By and Through Her Mother Samantha Rickard, as Parent and Next FriendDecided Vote MajorityAuthored12-1117Tribal immunity from state lawsuitsMichigan v. Bay Mills Indian CommunityDecided Vote Dissent12-515Discrimination against protestersTim Wood and Rob Savage v. Michael MossDecided Vote Majority13-115Delay in copyright claimsPaula Petrella v. Metro-Goldwyn-Mayer, Inc.Decided Vote Majority12-1315Fees for baseless patent claimsHighmark Inc. v. Allcare Health Management System, Inc.Decided Vote Majority12-1163Cross-state air pollution limitsEnvironmental Protection Agency v. EME Homer City Generation, L.P.Decided Vote Recusal12-1182Attorney fees in patent suitsOctane Fitness, LLC v. ICON Health & Fitness, Inc.Decided Vote Majority12-1184Jury instructions on silenceRandy White, Warden v. Robert Keith WoodallDecided Vote Majority12-794Restitution for victim lossesDoyle Randall Paroline v. United StatesDecided Vote Majority12-8561Voter bans on affirmative actionBill Schuette, Attorney General of Michigan v. Coalition to Defend Affirmative Action, Integration and Immigrant Rights and Fight for Equality By Any Means Necessary (BAMN)Decided Vote Majority12-682Traffic stops based on tipsLorenzo Prado Navarette and Jose Prado Navarette v. CaliforniaDecided Vote Majority12-9490Airline loyalty program claimsNorthwest, Inc. v. Rabbi S. Binyomin GinsbergDecided Vote MajorityAuthored12-462Campaign donation limitsShaun McCutcheon v. Federal Election CommissionDecided Vote Majority12-536Domestic violence gun bansUnited States v. James Alvin CastlemanDecided Vote ConcurrenceAuthored12-1371Payroll taxes on severance payUnited States v. Quality Stores, Inc.Decided Vote Majority12-1408False ad lawsuit rulesLexmark International, Inc. v. Static Control Components, Inc.Decided Vote Majority12-873Railroad land ownershipMarvin M. Brandt Revocable Trust v. United StatesDecided Vote Majority12-1173Who decides arbitration requirementsBG Group plc v. Republic of ArgentinaDecided Vote Majority12-138Deadline to return abducted childrenManuel Jose Lozano v. Diana Lucia Montoya AlvarezDecided Vote MajorityAuthored12-820Intent to help use gunsJustus C. Rosemond v. United StatesDecided Vote DissentAuthored12-895Whistleblower protection for contractorsJackie Hosang Lawson and Jonathan M. Zang v. FMR LLCDecided Vote Dissent12-3Protected home equity in bankruptcyStephen Law v. Alfred H. Siegel, Chapter 7 TrusteeDecided Vote Majority12-5196Trespassing on military roadsUnited States v. John Dennis ApelDecided Vote MajorityAuthored12-1038State securities class actionsChadbourne & Parke LLP v. Samuel TroiceDecided Vote Dissent12-79Court power over out-of-state defendantsAnthony Walden v. Gina FioreDecided Vote Majority12-574Home searches with roommate consentWalter Fernandez v. CaliforniaDecided Vote MajorityAuthored12-7822Immunity for security reportsAir Wisconsin Airlines Corporation v. William L. HoeperDecided Vote Majority12-315Pay for changing safety gearClifton Sandifer v. United States Steel CorporationDecided Vote Majority12-417When drugs cause deathMarcus Andrew Burrage v. United StatesDecided Vote Majority12-7515Who proves patent infringementMedtronic, Inc. v. Mirowski Family Ventures, LLCDecided Vote Majority12-1128Appealing before fees are decidedRay Haluch Gravel Company v. Central Pension Fund of the International Union of Operating Engineers and Participating EmployersDecided Vote Majority12-992Group lawsuits in federal courtMississippi, ex rel. Jim Hood, Attorney General v. AU Optronics CorporationDecided Vote Majority12-1036Disability benefit lawsuit deadlinesJulie Heimeshoff v. Hartford Life & Accident Insurance Co.Decided Vote Majority12-729Mental exams and self-incriminationKansas v. Scott D. CheeverDecided Vote Majority12-609Waiting for state enforcementSprint Communications, Inc. v. Elizabeth S. JacobsDecided Vote Majority12-815Tax penalties for inflated valuesUnited States v. Gary WoodsDecided Vote Majority12-562Agreements on where to sueAtlantic Marine Construction Company, Inc. v. United States District Court for the Western District of TexasDecided Vote MajorityAuthored12-929Lawyer advice on plea dealsSherry L. Burt, Warden v. Vonlee Nicole TitlowDecided Vote MajorityAuthored12-414

Agreement with other justices

October Term 2013 (2013–2014)

Share of decided cases this term in which Justice Samuel A. Alito, Jr. voted on the same side of the judgment as each other justice
JusticeAgreementCases together
Clarence Thomas95%57 of 60
Antonin Scalia90%54 of 60
Anthony M. Kennedy87%52 of 60
John G. Roberts, Jr.85%51 of 60
Stephen G. Breyer78%46 of 59
Elena Kagan78%45 of 58
Sonia Sotomayor75%44 of 59
Ruth Bader Ginsburg73%43 of 59

Methodology

Two justices agree in a case when they land on the same side of the judgment: voting with the majority, including concurrences, or in dissent together.

Vote records come from Oyez. A case counts only when at least 8 substantive votes are on record, so partial data can understate coverage but a vote is never invented. Recusals are listed but left out of agreement rates.

Term statisticsHow this site is made