No. 20-1775October Term 2020Decided Jun 15, 2022
Arizona v. City and County of San Francisco
For now, the key issue is who gets to defend the 2019 public charge rule in court, not a final Supreme Court answer on the rule itself.
Case status
- Current stage
- Decided
- Latest event
- Decision released Jun 15, 2022
- What it's about
This case arose from challenges to the federal government's 2019 immigration "public charge" rule. The main dispute at the Supreme Court was whether Arizona and other states could step in to defend that rule after the federal government stopped defending it, and, if so, whether the rule was lawful or the lower-court judgment should be wiped away as moot.
Question presented
1. Whether States with interests should be permitted to intervene to defend a rule when the United States ceases to defend. 2. Whether the Rule is contrary to law or arbitrary and capricious. 3. Alternatively, whether the decision below as to the Rule should be vacated as moot under Munsingwear.
- Case path
United States Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit / Decision released Jun 15, 2022
- Area
Immigration
Briefing
What it's about
The case grows out of fights over the federal government's 2019 immigration "public charge" rule. The Supreme Court is being asked whether Arizona and other states can step in to defend that rule after the federal government stopped defending it, and, if so, whether the rule was lawful or the lower-court judgment should be erased as moot (no longer live).
Vote
The case is still pending, and no oral argument has been scheduled yet. Arizona and other states say they should be allowed to defend the 2019 rule if the United States stops defending it.
Impact
The dispute could shape who gets to defend a federal policy in court when a new administration changes course. That matters for states, immigrants affected by the public charge rule, and federal agencies trying to revise immigration policy.
What's next
The next major step is a scheduling move from the Court, such as setting oral argument or taking other action in the case. No decision window is available yet.
What is the core dispute in Arizona v. City and County of San Francisco?
The main fight is whether Arizona and other states can defend the 2019 public charge rule after the federal government stopped defending it. The case also raises whether the rule was lawful or whether the lower-court judgment should be wiped away as moot.
Why could this case matter in the real world?
It could affect whether states can keep defending federal policies when presidential administrations change position. That can shape immigration rules and who must follow them while court fights continue.
What should people watch for next in this case?
Watch for the Supreme Court to schedule oral argument or make another procedural move. The record does not show any decision date yet.
Decision
What the Court decided
For now, the key issue is who gets to defend the 2019 public charge rule in court, not a final Supreme Court answer on the rule itself.
Impact
The dispute could shape who gets to defend a federal policy in court when a new administration changes course. That matters for states, immigrants affected by the public charge rule, and federal agencies trying to revise immigration policy.
Not official Court text.
Opinion documents
Timing
Decided June 15, 2022
The Court released its decision on June 15, 2022 without hearing oral argument.
Related cases




Grounding
- Grounding
- Primary materials plus reporting.
- Note
- Best-effort analysis: this explainer relies on a mix of primary materials and trusted secondary sources. Official filings and opinions remain authoritative.
- Checked
- Jul 2, 2026
- Method
- Methodology
Primary materials9
Supreme Court docket 20-1775
docket | Jul 25, 2026
Primary case document
Supreme Court document | Jul 25, 2026
CourtListener docket record
docket | Jul 25, 2026
Questions Presented
brief | May 24, 2026
Opinion
opinion | Jun 15, 2022
Petition
brief | Jun 18, 2021
SupremeCourt.gov
official | Jul 2, 2026
SupremeCourt.gov
official | Jul 2, 2026
SupremeCourt.gov
official | Jul 2, 2026