Skip to main content

Cases compared

Ghosh v. New York City Housing Authority vs. William Wayne Stedman v. Texas vs. United States and Texas v. Abbott

No. 26-5403No. 26-5595No. 26-5685

Side by side

Ghosh v. New York City Housing Authority vs. William Wayne Stedman v. Texas vs. United States and Texas v. Abbott, compared fact by fact
FactShyamal Ghosh v. New York City Housing AuthorityWilliam Wayne Stedman v. TexasUnited States and Texas, ex rel. Ruth Torres v. Greg Abbott, Governor of Texas
DocketShyamal Ghosh v. New York City Housing Authority26-5403William Wayne Stedman v. Texas26-5595United States and Texas, ex rel. Ruth Torres v. Greg Abbott, Governor of Texas26-5685
StatusShyamal Ghosh v. New York City Housing AuthorityDismissedWilliam Wayne Stedman v. TexasDismissedUnited States and Texas, ex rel. Ruth Torres v. Greg Abbott, Governor of TexasDismissed
DateShyamal Ghosh v. New York City Housing AuthorityOctober Term 2026 (2026–2027)William Wayne Stedman v. TexasOctober Term 2026 (2026–2027)United States and Texas, ex rel. Ruth Torres v. Greg Abbott, Governor of TexasOctober Term 2026 (2026–2027)
Question presentedShyamal Ghosh v. New York City Housing Authority1. Whether, consistent with Thomas v. Am, 474 U.S. 140 (1985), a court of appeals may refuse to excuse a pro se litigant’s failure to object to a magistrate judge’s report and recommendation under the nonjurisdictional forfeiture rule when the record reflects health-related and communication difficulties affecting compliance with court deadlines. 2. Whether a court of appeals may treat the failure to object to a magistrate judge’s report and recommendation as a complete bar to appellate merits review of a pro se litigant’s federal employment discrimination claims, where those claims were dismissed at the pleading stage before any factual record was developed through discovery.William Wayne Stedman v. Texas1. Whether a state criminal conviction entered without a valid indictment deprives the trial court of subject-matter jurisdiction in violation of the Due Process Clause of the Fourteenth Amendment. 2. Whether state courts violate the Due Process and Equal Protection Clauses of the Fourteenth Amendment by refusing to adjudicate a properly presented challenge to subject-matter jurisdiction in post-conviction proceedings. 3. Whether an indigent prisoner seeking post-conviction habeas corpus relief is constitutionally entitled, upon a showing of particularized need, to obtain trial transcripts and other court records necessary to present constitutional claims.United States and Texas, ex rel. Ruth Torres v. Greg Abbott, Governor of Texas1. Whether Constitional violations occur when federal judiciary fails to recuse as statutorily required, fails to provide de novo review of magistrates sua sponte dismissal of §1983 claims on the basis of judicial immunity denying a suspect class whistleblower relief from constitutional violations confirmed by sanction from the state judicial commission? 2. Circuit split on False Claims Act structural and procedural process, whether: i. sua sponte dismissal during the seal period — prior to notice or intervention from the United States ripens jurisdiction — violates separation-of-powers and denies litigants ’ due process and equal protection; ii. FCA imposes a duty on the government to investigate prior to issuing notice; and iii. FCA claims may be advanced by pro se litigants or should be dismissed to benefit a hypothetical “ better ” litigant that can afford an attorney.
SummaryShyamal Ghosh v. New York City Housing AuthorityGhosh asks whether the Second Circuit could refuse to excuse his missed deadline to object to a magistrate judge’s recommendation and bar review of employment-discrimination claims against the New York City Housing Authority, dismissed before discovery. He cites health and communication difficulties; the Court distributed his petition for conference, leaving Supreme Court review unresolved.William Wayne Stedman v. TexasWilliam Wayne Stedman asks the Supreme Court to review his Texas conviction, arguing it was entered without a valid indictment and challenging Texas courts’ refusal to consider his post-conviction challenge and provide records he says he needs. The petition was distributed for a conference, which does not decide the claims.United States and Texas, ex rel. Ruth Torres v. Greg Abbott, Governor of TexasRuth Torres asks the Supreme Court to review the dismissal of her civil-rights and False Claims Act claims, alleging that judges failed to recuse or properly review her case and that officials retaliated against her as a whistleblower. The petition is listed for a conference; that listing is not an agreement to hear the case.

Relationship

Shared issue
Civil Rights
Why compared
Reviewed Civil Rights tags connect these current-term public cases.

Related

Sources

  • Built from reviewed issue tags and official docket records. Status lines and questions presented come from the tracked case data.