Skip to main content

Cases compared

Kevin Isaac Montoya Palacios v. Vernon Liggins vs. Trump v. Badar Khan Suri vs. Reguli v. Hetzel

No. 25-1223No. 26-380No. 26-501

Side by side

Kevin Isaac Montoya Palacios v. Vernon Liggins vs. Trump v. Badar Khan Suri vs. Reguli v. Hetzel, compared fact by fact
FactKevin Isaac Montoya Palacios v. Vernon Liggins, Acting Field Office Director, Baltimore, Maryland, Immigration and Customs EnforcementDonald J. Trump, President of the United States v. Badar Khan SuriConnie L. Reguli v. Tracy Hetzel
DocketKevin Isaac Montoya Palacios v. Vernon Liggins, Acting Field Office Director, Baltimore, Maryland, Immigration and Customs Enforcement25-1223Donald J. Trump, President of the United States v. Badar Khan Suri26-380Connie L. Reguli v. Tracy Hetzel26-501
StatusKevin Isaac Montoya Palacios v. Vernon Liggins, Acting Field Office Director, Baltimore, Maryland, Immigration and Customs EnforcementBefore ArgumentsDonald J. Trump, President of the United States v. Badar Khan SuriBefore ArgumentsConnie L. Reguli v. Tracy HetzelBefore Arguments
DateKevin Isaac Montoya Palacios v. Vernon Liggins, Acting Field Office Director, Baltimore, Maryland, Immigration and Customs EnforcementArgued Jan 11, 2027Donald J. Trump, President of the United States v. Badar Khan SuriOctober Term 2026 (2026–2027)Connie L. Reguli v. Tracy HetzelOctober Term 2026 (2026–2027)
Question presentedKevin Isaac Montoya Palacios v. Vernon Liggins, Acting Field Office Director, Baltimore, Maryland, Immigration and Customs EnforcementWhether, under EAJA, "any civil action" encompasses an action seeking a writ of habeas corpus to challenge civil immigration detention?Donald J. Trump, President of the United States v. Badar Khan SuriWhether, notwithstanding 8 U.S.C. 1252, an alien detained pending his removal proceedings may challenge that detention in a habeas petition based on claims that also go to the validity of his being removed?Connie L. Reguli v. Tracy Hetzel1. If probable cause of criminal conduct is required, then this Court must determine the limitations of Fourth Amendment “reasonableness” when state actors fabricate a crime by knowingly and intentionally removing an essential element from the statutory language. 2. Whether prosecutorial immunity can protect prosecutors who intentionally prepare an indictment fabricating a crime by rewriting the statutory language and removing an essential element of the crime knowing that the citizen’s conduct does not rise to a criminal offense? 3. Whether, in a Fed. R. Civ. Proc. 12 review, the tribunal can sua sponte insert legal arguments not briefed, and alter the facts plead by the Plaintiffs to fashion absolute and qualified immunity while avoiding well-established case law and arguments made by the Plaintiff/Appellants sheering away Fourth Amendment rights for future litigants?
SummaryKevin Isaac Montoya Palacios v. Vernon Liggins, Acting Field Office Director, Baltimore, Maryland, Immigration and Customs EnforcementThis case asks whether a person who wins a habeas corpus challenge to civil immigration detention may recover attorney’s fees and costs from the federal government under the Equal Access to Justice Act. The Court will decide whether such a habeas case counts as a “civil action” under that law.Donald J. Trump, President of the United States v. Badar Khan SuriThe Trump administration has asked the Supreme Court to review whether Badar Khan Suri, who is detained while removal proceedings are pending, may challenge his detention in court based on claims that also contest his removal.Connie L. Reguli v. Tracy HetzelConnie L. Reguli and other petitioners ask the Supreme Court to review claims that state actors fabricated a crime by removing an essential element from a statute and that prosecutors prepared an indictment knowing the alleged conduct was not criminal. They also challenge a court’s use of unbriefed arguments and changes to pleaded facts when applying immunity.

Relationship

Shared issue
Criminal Procedure
Why compared
Reviewed Criminal Procedure tags connect these current-term public cases.

Related

Sources

  • Built from reviewed issue tags and official docket records. Status lines and questions presented come from the tracked case data.