Skip to main content
Supreme Court Case Tracker
The Court, in plain English
Cases
Topics
Calendar
Justices
Emergency docket
Statistics
Home
Cases
Calendar
Justices
Menu
Home
/
Cases
/
October Term 2011 (2011–2012)
/
Page 2
By term
October Term 2011 (2011–2012)
October Term 2011
·
73 cases
·
Page 2
All cases
Latest updates
Upcoming arguments
Awaiting decision
Recent decisions
OT
2026
Before Arguments
Awaiting Decision
Decided
Dismissed
Search
49–73 of 73 cases · October Term 2011 · by latest update
Previous
Page 2 of 2
Next
Status
Case
Date
Docket
Decided
GPS tracking without a warrant
United States v. Antoine Jones
The Supreme Court ruled that the government’s attachment of a GPS tracker to Antoine Jones’s vehicle and use of it to monitor the vehicle’s movements was a search under the Fourth Amendment. It agreed with the lower court (affirmed its ruling).
Decided
Jan 23, 2012
10-1259
Decided
When lawyers abandon clients
Cory R. Maples v. Kim T. Thomas, Commissioner, Alabama Department of Corrections
The Supreme Court ruled that Cory Maples had a valid excuse (“cause”) for missing Alabama’s deadline to appeal the denial of his state post-conviction petition because his lawyers had abandoned him without telling him. It overturned the appeals court’s ruling and sent the case back to the lower court (remanded).
Decided
Jan 18, 2012
10-63
Decided
Finding missing witnesses
Marcus Hardy, Warden v. Irving L. Cross
Irving Cross challenged the use of A.S.’s earlier testimony at his retrial, arguing prosecutors had not made the good-faith effort to find her required by the Confrontation Clause. The Supreme Court overturned the Seventh Circuit’s judgment (reversed it).
Decided
Dec 12, 2011
11-74
Decided
Evidence withheld from defense
Juan Smith v. Burl Cain, Warden
The Supreme Court overturned Juan Smith’s murder conviction because Louisiana withheld an eyewitness’s earlier statements that he could not identify the killers; the eyewitness was the only evidence linking Smith to the murders. The Court sent the case back to the lower court (remanded), finding that withholding the statements undermined confidence in the verdict.
Decided
Jan 10, 2012
10-8145
Decided
Later rulings in prisoner appeals
Eric Greene, aka Jarmaine Q. Trice v. Jon Fisher, Superintendent, State Correctional Institution at Smithfield
Greene sought federal relief based on Gray, a Supreme Court decision issued after Pennsylvania’s last ruling on his claim. The Supreme Court agreed with the Third Circuit that Gray was not “clearly established federal law” for reviewing the earlier ruling; the state decision did not meet the law’s standard for federal relief.
Decided
Nov 8, 2011
10-637
Decided
Robocall lawsuits in federal court
Marcus D. Mims v. Arrow Financial Services, LLC
Marcus Mims sued Arrow Financial Services, claiming it violated the Telephone Consumer Protection Act. The Supreme Court unanimously overturned the lower courts’ ruling that only state courts could hear his claim and sent the case back to the lower court (remanded), deciding that state courts’ authority to hear private TCPA suits does not take away federal courts’ authority to hear them.
Decided
Jan 18, 2012
10-1195
Decided
Deadline to challenge a conviction
Rafael Arriaza Gonzalez v. Rick Thaler, Director, Texas Department of Criminal Justice, Correctional Institutions Division
Gonzalez challenged the Fifth Circuit’s authority to hear his appeal and whether his federal challenge to his conviction was too late. The Supreme Court said a certificate of appealability (permission to appeal) must identify a constitutional issue, but that omission did not bar the Fifth Circuit from hearing the appeal; it left the court’s judgment in place.
Decided
Jan 10, 2012
10-895
Decided
Suing private prison workers
Margaret Minneci v. Richard Lee Pollard
Richard Lee Pollard, a federal prisoner in a privately run prison, sought damages from prison employees for alleged Eighth Amendment violations. The Supreme Court ruled that he could not bring a federal constitutional damages claim (a Bivens claim) in these circumstances because state tort law provided adequate ways to seek compensation and deter misconduct, and it overturned the Ninth Circuit’s rulings.
Decided
Jan 10, 2012
10-1104
Decided
Reviewing expert evidence
Javier Cavazos, Acting Warden v. Shirley Ree Smith
Shirley Ree Smith, convicted in her infant grandson’s death, received relief from the Ninth Circuit after it found the evidence insufficient amid conflicting expert testimony about the cause of death. Acting warden Javier Cavazos asked the Supreme Court to overturn that ruling; the Court did so and sent the case back for further proceedings (remanded).
Decided
Oct 31, 2011
10-1115
Decided
Police liability for searches
Curt Messerschmidt v. Brenda Millender, as of the Estate of Augusta Millender
Augusta Millender’s estate challenged a warrant to search her home for firearms and gang-related items after Jerry Bowen allegedly used a sawed-off shotgun to attack his former girlfriend. The Supreme Court ruled the officers were protected by qualified immunity (protection from civil damages unless officials violate a clearly established legal right) and overturned the Ninth Circuit’s ruling against them.
Decided
Feb 22, 2012
10-704
Decided
Nursing home arbitration agreements
Marmet Health Care Center, Inc. v. Clayton Brown
The children of nursing-home patients sued the homes for negligence after the patients died in their care; West Virginia’s high court held that agreements the children signed requiring arbitration were invalid under public policy. The Supreme Court wiped out that judgment (vacated it) and sent the cases back for further proceedings (remanded).
Decided
Feb 21, 2012
11-391
Decided
Fiscal year for worker benefits
Dana Roberts v. Sea-Land Services, Inc.
Dana Roberts and Sea-Land disputed which fiscal year's wages set the Longshore Act's cap on disability benefits: the year Roberts first became entitled to benefits or the year a formal compensation award was issued. The Supreme Court agreed with the Ninth Circuit (affirmed its ruling), deciding the relevant year is when a worker first becomes disabled and entitled to benefits, regardless of when an order is issued.
Decided
Mar 20, 2012
10-1399
Decided
Tribal contract funding cap
Ken L. Salazar, Secretary of the Interior v. Ramah Navajo Chapter
The Supreme Court agreed with the Tenth Circuit that the federal government must pay tribes’ full contract-support costs under the Indian Self-Determination and Education Assistance Act, even when the total amount due exceeds the statutory funding cap.
Decided
Jun 18, 2012
11-551
Decided
Help with trial lawyer claims
Luis Mariano Martinez v. Charles L. Ryan, Director, Arizona Department of Corrections
The Supreme Court ruled that if state law requires a person to raise a claim that trial counsel was ineffective in the first post-conviction case (a court challenge after conviction), the person may sometimes overcome the state’s rule blocking review if there was no lawyer, or an ineffective lawyer, in that case and the trial-counsel claim has some merit. The Court overturned the Ninth Circuit and sent Luis Martinez’s case back to the lower court (remanded); whether his post-conviction lawyer performed inadequately, his trial-counsel claim had merit, and he was harmed remained undecided.
Decided
Mar 20, 2012
10-1001
Decided
Lender bids in bankruptcy
RadLAX Gateway Hotel, LLC v. Amalgamated Bank
The Supreme Court agreed with the Seventh Circuit that RadLAX could not get approval for a Chapter 11 plan to sell hotel collateral free of Amalgamated Bank’s lien while barring the bank from bidding with the debt it was owed (credit-bidding).
Decided
May 29, 2012
11-166
Decided
Deportation relief after conviction
Joel Judulang v. Eric H. Holder, Jr., Attorney General
The Supreme Court ruled that the Board of Immigration Appeals’ rule for deciding whether Joel Judulang could seek discretionary relief from deportation under a former immigration law was unreasonable under the law governing federal agencies (arbitrary and capricious). It overturned the Ninth Circuit’s ruling and sent Judulang’s case back to the lower court (remanded).
Decided
Dec 12, 2011
10-694
Decided
Court challenges to EPA orders
Chantell Sackett, et vir v. Environmental Protection Agency
The Sacketts challenged an EPA Clean Water Act order concerning their Idaho land. The Court ruled they could sue under federal law allowing court review of agency actions to challenge EPA’s authority to regulate it, overturned the Ninth Circuit’s ruling, and sent the case back (reversed and remanded); whether they could challenge the order’s terms remains unresolved.
Decided
Mar 21, 2012
10-1062
Decided
After-death child benefits
Michael J. Astrue, Commissioner of Social Security v. Karen K. Capato, on Behalf of B. N. C.
The Supreme Court ruled that the Social Security Administration could use state inheritance law to decide whether Karen Capato’s twins, conceived after their father’s death, qualified for survivor benefits. It overturned the Third Circuit’s ruling and sent the case back to the lower court (remanded), without deciding the twins’ status under the relevant state law.
Decided
May 21, 2012
11-159
Decided
Federal employee court access
Michael B. Elgin v. Department of the Treasury
Michael Elgin and other former federal employees challenged their firings under a law requiring them to register for the military draft, arguing that the law was unconstitutional. The Supreme Court agreed with the First Circuit that covered employees must use the review process under the Civil Service Reform Act, even for constitutional challenges, and upheld the lower court’s ruling.
Decided
Jun 11, 2012
11-45
Decided
Offshore worker injury coverage
Pacific Operators Offshore, LLP v. Luisa L. Valladolid
Juan Valladolid died at an onshore facility; his widow sought workers’ compensation under a law covering offshore operations. The Court agreed with the Ninth Circuit and sent the case back to the lower court (remanded), ruling coverage requires a substantial connection between Valladolid’s injury and Pacific Operators Offshore’s offshore extraction work; whether that link exists remains unresolved.
Decided
Jan 11, 2012
10-507
Decided
Immunity for government-hired lawyers
Steve A. Filarsky v. Nicholas B. Delia
Rialto hired private lawyer Steve Filarsky to investigate firefighter Nicholas Delia, who later sued over alleged constitutional violations during the investigation; the dispute was whether Filarsky could claim qualified immunity (a defense against personal damages suits over government work) despite not being a city employee. The Supreme Court unanimously overturned the Ninth Circuit’s ruling that Filarsky’s private status alone barred him from seeking that defense, but did not decide whether he ultimately qualified for it.
Decided
Apr 17, 2012
10-1018
Decided
State immigration enforcement
Arizona v. United States
The United States challenged Arizona’s S.B. 1070 as conflicting with federal law. The Court ruled federal law blocks three parts—Sections 3, 5(C), and 6—but lifted the block on Section 2(B) because state courts had not interpreted it and no conflict had yet been shown; it sent the case back to the lower court (remanded).
Decided
Jun 25, 2012
11-182
Decided
Court costs for translations
Kouichi Taniguchi v. Kan Pacific Saipan, Ltd., dba Marianas Resort and Spa
The Supreme Court ruled that the law’s category for “compensation of interpreters” covers oral translation, not document-translation costs. It wiped out the Ninth Circuit’s ruling (vacated it) and sent the case back to the lower court (remanded it).
Decided
May 21, 2012
10-1472
Decided
Eyewitness identification evidence
Barion Perry v. New Hampshire
Barion Perry argued that a judge should check an eyewitness identification’s reliability even when law enforcement did not arrange the suggestive circumstances. The Supreme Court agreed with New Hampshire and upheld the state court’s ruling: judges need not screen reliability unless law enforcement arranged unnecessarily suggestive circumstances.
Decided
Jan 11, 2012
10-8974
Decided
Immunity for false testimony
Charles A. Rehberg v. James P. Paulk
Charles Rehberg sued investigator James Paulk over alleged false grand-jury testimony. The Supreme Court agreed with the lower court (affirmed), deciding that grand-jury witnesses have the same protection from damages suits under federal civil-rights law (§1983) based on their testimony as trial witnesses.
Decided
Apr 2, 2012
10-788
Previous
1
2
Next
Search
Search by case name, topic, or docket number.