Skip to main content

By term

October Term 2011 (2011–2012)

73 casesRecap
  • Before Arguments0
  • Awaiting Decision0
  • Decided73
  • Dismissed0
73 of 73 tracked cases in October Term 2011 (2011–2012) have a decision on the record.

Term tracker

Every published case, by stage

Decided Cases

73
DecidedFree speech and military medalsUnited States v. Xavier AlvarezXavier Alvarez challenged a federal law that made it a crime to falsely claim he had received a military medal. The Supreme Court agreed with the Ninth Circuit and left its ruling in place (affirmed it).Decided 11-210DecidedRight to sue over kickbacksFirst American Financial Corporation, Successor in Interest to The First American Corporation v. Denise P. EdwardsDenise Edwards sued First American over an alleged kickback connected to her title-insurance referral, raising whether a purchaser can sue under RESPA without claiming the kickback affected the service’s price or quality. The Supreme Court dismissed its review as improvidently granted (ended review after deciding it should not have agreed to hear the case), and did not decide that legal question.Decided 10-708DecidedHealth insurance requirementNational Federation of Independent Business v. SebeliusBusinesses and states challenged the Affordable Care Act’s insurance requirement and Medicaid expansion. The Supreme Court upheld the insurance requirement under Congress’s power to tax and ruled Congress could not threaten states with loss of existing Medicaid funds for refusing the expansion; it agreed with the lower court on some issues and overturned its ruling on others.Decided 11-393DecidedCorporate political spendingAmerican Tradition Partnership, Inc., fka Western Tradition Partnership, Inc. v. Steve Bullock, Attorney General of MontanaAmerican Tradition Partnership, Champion Painting, and the Montana Shooting Sports Association challenged a Montana law barring corporations from spending money in connection with candidates, saying it violated the First Amendment. The Supreme Court overturned the Montana Supreme Court’s judgment (reversed it).Decided 11-1179DecidedJuvenile life without paroleMiller v. AlabamaEvan Miller was 14 when he committed a homicide and received a mandatory sentence of life in prison without parole. The Supreme Court ruled that the Eighth Amendment bars laws requiring that sentence for juvenile homicide offenders, overturned the state court ruling in Miller’s case, and sent it back to the lower court (remanded).Decided 10-9646DecidedState immigration enforcementArizona v. United StatesThe United States challenged Arizona’s S.B. 1070 as conflicting with federal law. The Court ruled federal law blocks three parts—Sections 3, 5(C), and 6—but lifted the block on Section 2(B) because state courts had not interpreted it and no conflict had yet been shown; it sent the case back to the lower court (remanded).Decided 11-182DecidedCrack cocaine sentencing rulesEdward Dorsey, Sr. v. United StatesEdward Dorsey challenged the Seventh Circuit’s ruling that the Fair Sentencing Act did not cover all defendants sentenced after it took effect, even if their crimes came earlier. The Supreme Court wiped out the Seventh Circuit’s judgment and sent the case back to that court (vacated and remanded).Decided 11-5683DecidedUnion fees for political spendingDianne Knox v. Service Employees International Union, Local 1000The case concerned whether California could require public employees to pay SEIU Local 1000 a special charge for political spending without notice and a chance to object, and whether it could require union fees for ballot-measure spending. The Supreme Court overturned the Ninth Circuit’s judgment and sent the case back for further proceedings (reversed and remanded).Decided 10-1121DecidedJury trials for criminal finesSouthern Union Company v. United StatesSouthern Union Company challenged how a criminal fine was calculated, asking whether a jury must find facts that raise a fine above the statutory maximum. The Supreme Court overturned the First Circuit’s judgment and sent the case back to the lower court (remanded).Decided 11-94DecidedSuing over tribal land trustsMatch-E-Be-Nash-She-Wish Band of Pottawatomi Indians v. David PatchakPatchak challenged the government’s plan to hold land in trust for the Match-E-Be-Nash-She-Wish Band, and the government argued its protection from suit (sovereign immunity) barred his case. The Supreme Court ruled the government had waived that protection, agreed with the lower court, and sent the case back to the lower court (remanded).Decided 11-246DecidedQuestioning lab test witnessesWilliams v. IllinoisSandy Williams challenged his conviction after a prosecution expert testified about DNA testing performed by a lab analyst who did not testify. The Supreme Court left the Illinois judgment in place (affirmed); Justice Alito’s four-justice opinion concluded that this testimony did not violate Williams’s Sixth Amendment right to question witnesses (the Confrontation Clause), though the justices did not agree on a single rationale.Decided 10-8505DecidedDrug sales reps' overtime payMichael Shane Christopher v. SmithKline Beecham Corporation, dba GlaxoSmithKlineGlaxoSmithKline sales representatives Michael Christopher and Frank Buchanan sought overtime pay, disputing that their jobs fit the law’s exception from overtime rules for outside salespeople. The Supreme Court agreed with the Ninth Circuit that they qualified under the most reasonable reading of the Labor Department’s regulations.Decided 11-204DecidedTribal contract funding capKen L. Salazar, Secretary of the Interior v. Ramah Navajo ChapterThe Supreme Court agreed with the Tenth Circuit that the federal government must pay tribes’ full contract-support costs under the Indian Self-Determination and Education Assistance Act, even when the total amount due exceeds the statutory funding cap.Decided 11-551DecidedFederal review of state convictionsPhilip Parker, Warden v. David Eugene MatthewsIn David Matthews’s challenge to his Kentucky murder convictions, the Supreme Court overturned the Sixth Circuit’s judgment and sent the case back for further proceedings (remanded).Decided 11-845DecidedFederal employee court accessMichael B. Elgin v. Department of the TreasuryMichael Elgin and other former federal employees challenged their firings under a law requiring them to register for the military draft, arguing that the law was unconstitutional. The Supreme Court agreed with the First Circuit that covered employees must use the review process under the Civil Service Reform Act, even for constitutional challenges, and upheld the lower court’s ruling.Decided 11-45DecidedArrests for political speechVirgil D. "Gus" Reichle, Jr. v. Steven HowardsSteven Howards claimed Secret Service agents arrested him in retaliation for criticizing Vice President Cheney. The Supreme Court overturned the appeals court and sent the case back, ruling the agents were shielded from damages liability (qualified immunity) because it was not clearly established that an arrest supported by probable cause could violate the First Amendment; the Court did not decide whether such a right exists.Decided 11-262DecidedProperty assessment forgivenessChristine Armour v. City of Indianapolis, IndianaThe Supreme Court upheld the Indiana Supreme Court’s ruling that Indianapolis could forgive homeowners’ unpaid Barrett Law sewer-assessment balances without refunding those who had paid in full. It found the difference had a rational basis—a reasonable justification—and did not violate the Constitution’s equal-protection guarantee.Decided 11-161DecidedEvidence for a murder convictionBrian Coleman, Superintendent, State Correctional Institution at Fayette v. Lorenzo JohnsonLorenzo Johnson challenged the evidence supporting his first-degree murder conviction for Taraja Williams’s killing. The Supreme Court overturned the Third Circuit’s ruling, concluding that a rational jury could find Johnson intended to kill Williams, and sent the case back for further proceedings (remanded).Decided 11-1053DecidedLender bids in bankruptcyRadLAX Gateway Hotel, LLC v. Amalgamated BankThe Supreme Court agreed with the Seventh Circuit that RadLAX could not get approval for a Chapter 11 plan to sell hotel collateral free of Amalgamated Bank’s lien while barring the bank from bidding with the debt it was owed (credit-bidding).Decided 11-166DecidedMurder retrials after jury votesAlex Blueford v. ArkansasAfter the jury deadlocked, Alex Blueford argued that its forewoman’s announced unanimous votes against capital and first-degree murder were acquittals that barred a retrial. The Supreme Court ruled that double jeopardy did not bar Arkansas from retrying him on those charges and agreed with the Arkansas Supreme Court (affirmed its ruling).Decided 10-1320DecidedUnearned closing feesTammy Foret Freeman v. Quicken Loans, Inc.Tammy Foret Freeman and other borrowers said Quicken Loans charged them fees for settlement services that were not performed. The Court agreed with the Fifth Circuit that a provider violates Section 8(b) of the Real Estate Settlement Procedures Act only if the charge is divided between two or more people; an undivided fee is not covered.Decided 10-1042DecidedCounting parents' residency timeEric H. Holder, Jr., Attorney General v. Carlos Martinez GutierrezThe Supreme Court overturned the Ninth Circuit’s ruling that Carlos Martinez Gutierrez could count a parent’s time as a permanent resident and living in the United States toward his own eligibility to avoid removal. It decided the immigration board could reasonably require him to meet the five-year permanent-resident and seven-year U.S.-residence requirements himself, and sent the case back to the lower court (remanded).Decided 10-1542DecidedAfter-death child benefitsMichael J. Astrue, Commissioner of Social Security v. Karen K. Capato, on Behalf of B. N. C.The Supreme Court ruled that the Social Security Administration could use state inheritance law to decide whether Karen Capato’s twins, conceived after their father’s death, qualified for survivor benefits. It overturned the Third Circuit’s ruling and sent the case back to the lower court (remanded), without deciding the twins’ status under the relevant state law.Decided 11-159DecidedCourt costs for translationsKouichi Taniguchi v. Kan Pacific Saipan, Ltd., dba Marianas Resort and SpaThe Supreme Court ruled that the law’s category for “compensation of interpreters” covers oral translation, not document-translation costs. It wiped out the Ninth Circuit’s ruling (vacated it) and sent the case back to the lower court (remanded it).Decided 10-1472DecidedFarm sale tax debtLynwood D. Hall, et ux. v. United StatesLynwood and Brenda Hall wanted to treat federal income taxes from selling farm property after filing for Chapter 12 bankruptcy as a debt of the bankruptcy estate and have their plan discharge it. The Supreme Court agreed with the Ninth Circuit that the tax was not a debt of the estate and could not be collected or discharged through their plan.Decided 10-875DecidedIRS tax assessment deadlineUnited States v. Home Concrete & Supply, LLCHome Concrete & Supply’s dispute asked whether overstating the tax basis of sold property counts as omitted income, allowing the IRS six years to assess tax, and whether a Treasury regulation could support that view. The Supreme Court upheld the Fourth Circuit’s judgment.Decided 11-139DecidedWho can face torture lawsuitsMohamad v. Palestinian AuthorityAzzam Rahim’s family sought to hold the Palestinian Authority and Palestine Liberation Organization liable under the Torture Victim Protection Act for his torture and death. The Supreme Court agreed with the lower court that the Act allows claims only against natural persons, not organizations.Decided 11-88DecidedNew evidence in patent appealsDavid J. Kappos, Under Secretary of Commerce for Intellectual Property and Director, Patent and Trademark Office v. Gilbert P. HyattHyatt challenged the Patent and Trademark Office’s denial of his patent application in federal court. The Supreme Court agreed with the appeals court and sent the case back: he could offer new evidence under ordinary evidence and procedure rules, and the district court must decide disputed facts using both that evidence and the agency record.Decided 10-1219DecidedGeneric drug patent descriptionsCaraco Pharmaceutical Laboratories, Ltd. v. Novo Nordisk A/SCaraco challenged Novo Nordisk’s description of which uses its Prandin patent covered while seeking approval for a generic drug. The Supreme Court overturned the Federal Circuit and sent the case back (reversed and remanded), deciding that a generic maker may use the Hatch-Waxman Act’s counterclaim provision to correct a description that inaccurately says a patent covers a particular use.Decided 10-844DecidedImmunity for government-hired lawyersSteve A. Filarsky v. Nicholas B. DeliaRialto hired private lawyer Steve Filarsky to investigate firefighter Nicholas Delia, who later sued over alleged constitutional violations during the investigation; the dispute was whether Filarsky could claim qualified immunity (a defense against personal damages suits over government work) despite not being a city employee. The Supreme Court unanimously overturned the Ninth Circuit’s ruling that Filarsky’s private status alone barred him from seeking that defense, but did not decide whether he ultimately qualified for it.Decided 10-1018DecidedWhen trial mistakes matterAlexander Vasquez v. United StatesAlexander Vasquez challenged the Seventh Circuit’s conclusion that admitting conversations between Marina Perez and her husband was harmless error, arguing that the court focused on untainted evidence without considering the error’s possible effects. The Supreme Court ended its review without deciding whether the analysis was correct or violated Vasquez’s Sixth Amendment right to a jury trial; it dismissed the case as improvidently granted.Decided 11-199DecidedJail strip searchesAlbert W. Florence v. Board of Chosen Freeholders of the County of BurlingtonAlbert Florence challenged visual strip searches he underwent during jail intake after his arrest. The Supreme Court agreed with the Third Circuit that jails may require searches without individualized suspicion or physical contact by officers for people admitted to the general population; it did not decide whether that rule applies to people held separately.Decided 10-945DecidedImmunity for false testimonyCharles A. Rehberg v. James P. PaulkCharles Rehberg sued investigator James Paulk over alleged false grand-jury testimony. The Supreme Court agreed with the lower court (affirmed), deciding that grand-jury witnesses have the same protection from damages suits under federal civil-rights law (§1983) based on their testimony as trial witnesses.Decided 10-788DecidedOrder of prison sentencesMonroe Ace Setser v. United StatesMonroe Ace Setser challenged a federal judge’s order that his federal sentence run after an expected state sentence for a probation violation, even though the state sentence had not yet been imposed. The Supreme Court agreed with the lower court (affirmed) that the judge had discretion to order that sequence.Decided 10-7387DecidedEmotional distress damagesFederal Aviation Administration v. Stanmore Cawthon CooperAfter Stanmore Cooper’s HIV status reached the FAA and his pilot certificate was revoked, he sought damages for emotional distress under the Privacy Act. The Supreme Court ruled that the Act did not clearly let people recover such damages from the federal government, overturned the Ninth Circuit’s ruling, and sent the case back to that court (remanded).Decided 10-1024DecidedGreen card travel after convictionPanagis Vartelas v. Eric H. Holder, Jr., Attorney GeneralPanagis Vartelas, a green-card holder who pleaded guilty to a crime before a 1996 immigration law took effect, challenged how that law affected his permanent-resident status after a later brief trip abroad. The Supreme Court ruled that the effect of his trip was governed by the law in force when he pleaded guilty, overturned the Second Circuit’s ruling, and sent the case back to that court (remanded).Decided 10-1211DecidedJerusalem on passportsMenachem Binyamin Zivotofsky, By His Parents and Guardians, Ari Z. and Naomi Siegman Zivotofsky v. Hillary Rodham Clinton, Secretary of StateMenachem Zivotofsky, born in Jerusalem, sought to list Israel as his birthplace on his passport and consular birth report under federal law; the State Department refused. The Court ruled courts could hear the claim, wiped out the appeals court’s judgment (vacated it), and sent the case back (remanded), without deciding whether Zivotofsky was entitled to the listing.Decided 10-699DecidedInsider profit lawsuit deadlinesCredit Suisse Securities (USA) LLC v. Vanessa SimmondsVanessa Simmonds’ claims against Credit Suisse and other banks turned on the two-year deadline for securities-law claims. The Court rejected the Ninth Circuit’s rule that the deadline pauses until an insider files a disclosure, wiped out that ruling (vacated it), and sent the case back (remanded); the justices were evenly divided on whether the deadline can otherwise be extended.Decided 10-1261DecidedLawyer advice on plea dealsBlaine Lafler v. Anthony CooperAnthony Cooper’s lawyer gave inadequate advice that led him to reject a plea offer; the Supreme Court ruled there was a reasonable chance Cooper and the trial court would have accepted it, and that it would have led to a less severe outcome than trial. The Court wiped out the Sixth Circuit’s ruling (vacated it) and sent the case back for further proceedings (remanded).Decided 10-209DecidedSharing plea offersMissouri v. FryeFrye said his lawyer failed to tell him about a formal plea offer before he pleaded guilty. The Court ruled lawyers generally must communicate formal offers, even if they expire or are rejected, and wiped out the Missouri appeals court’s ruling and sent the case back (vacated and remanded); to obtain relief, Frye must show a reasonable chance he would have accepted the offer and that prosecutors and a court empowered by state law would have allowed the plea.Decided 10-444DecidedCourt challenges to EPA ordersChantell Sackett, et vir v. Environmental Protection AgencyThe Sacketts challenged an EPA Clean Water Act order concerning their Idaho land. The Court ruled they could sue under federal law allowing court review of agency actions to challenge EPA’s authority to regulate it, overturned the Ninth Circuit’s ruling, and sent the case back (reversed and remanded); whether they could challenge the order’s terms remains unresolved.Decided 10-1062DecidedState protection from leave lawsuitsDaniel Coleman v. Court of Appeals of MarylandDaniel Coleman, a former Maryland Court of Appeals employee, alleged he was fired after requesting medical leave under the Family and Medical Leave Act’s self-care provision. The Supreme Court upheld dismissal of his claim, concluding that state immunity bars damages suits under that provision.Decided 10-1016DecidedPatents on medical testsMayo Collaborative Services, dba Mayo Medical Laboratories v. Prometheus Laboratories, Inc.Prometheus held patents on methods for using test results to guide drug doses and sued Mayo over a similar test. The Supreme Court overturned the appeals court and ruled that Prometheus’s process was not eligible for a patent because it relied on a law of nature.Decided 10-1150DecidedFiscal year for worker benefitsDana Roberts v. Sea-Land Services, Inc.Dana Roberts and Sea-Land disputed which fiscal year's wages set the Longshore Act's cap on disability benefits: the year Roberts first became entitled to benefits or the year a formal compensation award was issued. The Supreme Court agreed with the Ninth Circuit (affirmed its ruling), deciding the relevant year is when a worker first becomes disabled and entitled to benefits, regardless of when an order is issued.Decided 10-1399DecidedHelp with trial lawyer claimsLuis Mariano Martinez v. Charles L. Ryan, Director, Arizona Department of CorrectionsThe Supreme Court ruled that if state law requires a person to raise a claim that trial counsel was ineffective in the first post-conviction case (a court challenge after conviction), the person may sometimes overcome the state’s rule blocking review if there was no lawyer, or an ineffective lawyer, in that case and the trial-counsel claim has some merit. The Court overturned the Ninth Circuit and sent Luis Martinez’s case back to the lower court (remanded); whether his post-conviction lawyer performed inadequately, his trial-counsel claim had merit, and he was harmed remained undecided.Decided 10-1001DecidedReplacing a court-appointed lawyerMichael Martel, Warden v. Kenneth ClairWhile challenging his death sentence in federal court, Kenneth Clair asked for a new court-appointed lawyer, saying he was dissatisfied and his lawyer was not pursuing important evidence. The Supreme Court overturned the Ninth Circuit’s ruling and sent the case back (remanded), deciding that the trial court acted within its discretion when it denied Clair’s second request under the “interests of justice” standard.Decided 10-1265DecidedRailroad safety lawsuitsGloria Gail Kurns, of the Estate of George M. Corson v. Railroad Friction Products CorporationGloria Kurns and Freida Corson, representing George Corson’s estate, brought state-law design-defect and failure-to-warn claims related to his alleged asbestos exposure. The Supreme Court agreed with the lower court that the Locomotive Inspection Act bars those claims because they fall within federal regulation of locomotive equipment.Decided 10-879DecidedChallenges to Medicaid rate cutsToby Douglas, Director, California Department of Health Care Services v. Independent Living Center of Southern California, Inc.California providers and Medicaid recipients challenged state laws cutting provider payments, arguing the cuts conflicted with federal Medicaid rules. The Supreme Court wiped out the lower court rulings (vacated them) and sent the cases back to the Ninth Circuit (remanded them) to consider whether the lawsuits could proceed after federal officials approved the state laws; the Court did not resolve that question.Decided 09-958DecidedWho owns riverbedsPPL Montana, LLC v. MontanaPPL Montana disputed Montana’s claim that it owned the riverbeds beneath PPL’s dams and could charge for their use. The Supreme Court overturned the Montana Supreme Court’s ruling for Montana because it rested on a mistaken understanding of the rules for deciding whether riverbeds passed to a state at statehood, and sent the case back to the lower court (remanded).Decided 10-218DecidedPolice liability for searchesCurt Messerschmidt v. Brenda Millender, as of the Estate of Augusta MillenderAugusta Millender’s estate challenged a warrant to search her home for firearms and gang-related items after Jerry Bowen allegedly used a sawed-off shotgun to attack his former girlfriend. The Supreme Court ruled the officers were protected by qualified immunity (protection from civil damages unless officials violate a clearly established legal right) and overturned the Ninth Circuit’s ruling against them.Decided 10-704DecidedTax fraud and deportationAkio Kawashima, et ux. v. Eric H. Holder, Jr., Attorney GeneralThe Supreme Court upheld the Ninth Circuit’s ruling that Akio and Fusako Kawashima’s convictions for filing or helping prepare false federal corporate tax returns count as “aggravated felonies” (crimes that can make immigrants subject to deportation) when the government’s revenue loss exceeds $10,000.Decided 10-577DecidedFederal review of state court rulingsJohn E. Wetzel, Secretary, Pennsylvania Department of Corrections v. James LambertThe case asked whether the Third Circuit properly deferred to Pennsylvania courts when reviewing James Lambert’s claim concerning a police notation about a photo display that included Lawrence Woodlock. The Supreme Court wiped out the Third Circuit’s decision (vacated it) and sent the case back to that court (remanded it) for further proceedings, without finally resolving Lambert’s claim.Decided 11-38DecidedMiranda warnings for inmatesCarol Howes, Warden v. Randall Lee FieldsThe Supreme Court overturned the Sixth Circuit, ruling that imprisonment and private questioning about another crime do not automatically require Miranda warnings; courts must consider the full interview. The Court found Randall Fields was not in custody requiring those warnings because officers repeatedly told him he could end the interview and return to his cell.Decided 10-680DecidedNursing home arbitration agreementsMarmet Health Care Center, Inc. v. Clayton BrownThe children of nursing-home patients sued the homes for negligence after the patients died in their care; West Virginia’s high court held that agreements the children signed requiring arbitration were invalid under public policy. The Supreme Court wiped out that judgment (vacated it) and sent the cases back for further proceedings (remanded).Decided 11-391DecidedSex offender registration timingBilly Joe Reynolds v. United StatesThe Supreme Court decided that the Sex Offender Registration and Notification Act does not require people convicted before its enactment to register until the Attorney General validly makes the law’s registration requirements apply to them. It overturned the Third Circuit’s ruling and sent the case back to the lower court (remanded).Decided 10-6549DecidedWarrantless home entryRyburn v. HuffThe case concerned police officers entering a home without a warrant after the homeowner’s behavior led them to fear danger. The Supreme Court overturned the Ninth Circuit’s ruling and sent the case back to that court for a judgment in favor of the officers (remanded).Decided 11-208DecidedGPS tracking without a warrantUnited States v. Antoine JonesThe Supreme Court ruled that the government’s attachment of a GPS tracker to Antoine Jones’s vehicle and use of it to monitor the vehicle’s movements was a search under the Fourth Amendment. It agreed with the lower court (affirmed its ruling).Decided 10-1259DecidedRedrawing voting districtsRick Perry, Governor of Texas v. Shannon PerezGovernor Rick Perry challenged interim Texas voting maps drawn by a federal district court for the 2012 elections. The Supreme Court wiped out the orders putting the maps in place (vacated them) and sent the cases back to the district court (remanded) because it was unclear whether the court used the proper standards.Decided 11-713DecidedCopyrights on public domain worksGolan v. HolderLawrence Golan and other artists challenged a law that restored U.S. copyright protection to some foreign works they had used while the works were in the public domain. The Supreme Court upheld the law, ruling that it fit Congress’s Copyright Clause powers and did not violate the First Amendment; it agreed with the lower court.Decided 10-545DecidedWhen lawyers abandon clientsCory R. Maples v. Kim T. Thomas, Commissioner, Alabama Department of CorrectionsThe Supreme Court ruled that Cory Maples had a valid excuse (“cause”) for missing Alabama’s deadline to appeal the denial of his state post-conviction petition because his lawyers had abandoned him without telling him. It overturned the appeals court’s ruling and sent the case back to the lower court (remanded).Decided 10-63DecidedRobocall lawsuits in federal courtMarcus D. Mims v. Arrow Financial Services, LLCMarcus Mims sued Arrow Financial Services, claiming it violated the Telephone Consumer Protection Act. The Supreme Court unanimously overturned the lower courts’ ruling that only state courts could hear his claim and sent the case back to the lower court (remanded), deciding that state courts’ authority to hear private TCPA suits does not take away federal courts’ authority to hear them.Decided 10-1195DecidedReligious teachers' discrimination suitsHosanna-Tabor Evangelical Lutheran Church and School v. Equal Employment Opportunity CommissionCheryl Perich, a Lutheran schoolteacher who taught religion and led worship, sued after Hosanna-Tabor fired her, alleging disability discrimination. The Supreme Court unanimously overturned the Sixth Circuit and ruled that the First Amendment required her suit to be thrown out because she was a minister covered by the ministerial exception, a rule barring ministers’ employment-discrimination suits against religious groups.Decided 10-553DecidedOffshore worker injury coveragePacific Operators Offshore, LLP v. Luisa L. ValladolidJuan Valladolid died at an onshore facility; his widow sought workers’ compensation under a law covering offshore operations. The Court agreed with the Ninth Circuit and sent the case back to the lower court (remanded), ruling coverage requires a substantial connection between Valladolid’s injury and Pacific Operators Offshore’s offshore extraction work; whether that link exists remains unresolved.Decided 10-507DecidedEyewitness identification evidenceBarion Perry v. New HampshireBarion Perry argued that a judge should check an eyewitness identification’s reliability even when law enforcement did not arrange the suggestive circumstances. The Supreme Court agreed with New Hampshire and upheld the state court’s ruling: judges need not screen reliability unless law enforcement arranged unnecessarily suggestive circumstances.Decided 10-8974DecidedEvidence withheld from defenseJuan Smith v. Burl Cain, WardenThe Supreme Court overturned Juan Smith’s murder conviction because Louisiana withheld an eyewitness’s earlier statements that he could not identify the killers; the eyewitness was the only evidence linking Smith to the murders. The Court sent the case back to the lower court (remanded), finding that withholding the statements undermined confidence in the verdict.Decided 10-8145DecidedDeadline to challenge a convictionRafael Arriaza Gonzalez v. Rick Thaler, Director, Texas Department of Criminal Justice, Correctional Institutions DivisionGonzalez challenged the Fifth Circuit’s authority to hear his appeal and whether his federal challenge to his conviction was too late. The Supreme Court said a certificate of appealability (permission to appeal) must identify a constitutional issue, but that omission did not bar the Fifth Circuit from hearing the appeal; it left the court’s judgment in place.Decided 10-895DecidedSuing private prison workersMargaret Minneci v. Richard Lee PollardRichard Lee Pollard, a federal prisoner in a privately run prison, sought damages from prison employees for alleged Eighth Amendment violations. The Supreme Court ruled that he could not bring a federal constitutional damages claim (a Bivens claim) in these circumstances because state tort law provided adequate ways to seek compensation and deter misconduct, and it overturned the Ninth Circuit’s rulings.Decided 10-1104DecidedFinding missing witnessesMarcus Hardy, Warden v. Irving L. CrossIrving Cross challenged the use of A.S.’s earlier testimony at his retrial, arguing prosecutors had not made the good-faith effort to find her required by the Confrontation Clause. The Supreme Court overturned the Seventh Circuit’s judgment (reversed it).Decided 11-74DecidedDeportation relief after convictionJoel Judulang v. Eric H. Holder, Jr., Attorney GeneralThe Supreme Court ruled that the Board of Immigration Appeals’ rule for deciding whether Joel Judulang could seek discretionary relief from deportation under a former immigration law was unreasonable under the law governing federal agencies (arbitrary and capricious). It overturned the Ninth Circuit’s ruling and sent Judulang’s case back to the lower court (remanded).Decided 10-694DecidedLater rulings in prisoner appealsEric Greene, aka Jarmaine Q. Trice v. Jon Fisher, Superintendent, State Correctional Institution at SmithfieldGreene sought federal relief based on Gray, a Supreme Court decision issued after Pennsylvania’s last ruling on his claim. The Supreme Court agreed with the Third Circuit that Gray was not “clearly established federal law” for reviewing the earlier ruling; the state decision did not meet the law’s standard for federal relief.Decided 10-637DecidedRights during police questioningDavid Bobby, Warden v. Archie DixonArchie Dixon challenged his statements to police, arguing that officers questioned him about forgery without Miranda warnings and delayed warnings until a later murder interrogation; he also disputed whether his statements were voluntary. The Supreme Court overturned the Sixth Circuit’s judgment and sent the case back for further proceedings (remanded).Decided 10-1540DecidedArbitration of some claimsKPMG LLP v. Robert CocchiInvestors sued KPMG over alleged accounting problems, and KPMG asked the court to send their claims to arbitration. The Supreme Court wiped out the Florida appeals court’s judgment and sent the case back to that court (vacated and remanded).Decided 10-1521DecidedReviewing expert evidenceJavier Cavazos, Acting Warden v. Shirley Ree SmithShirley Ree Smith, convicted in her infant grandson’s death, received relief from the Ninth Circuit after it found the evidence insufficient amid conflicting expert testimony about the cause of death. Acting warden Javier Cavazos asked the Supreme Court to overturn that ruling; the Court did so and sent the case back for further proceedings (remanded).Decided 10-1115