Skip to main content

Cases compared

Wilson v. AIM Specialty Health vs. Scott Drake Clabourne v. Arizona vs. James C. "Chris" McNeil v. Court of Common Pleas of South Carolina

No. 26-554No. 26-5571No. 26-562

Side by side

Wilson v. AIM Specialty Health vs. Scott Drake Clabourne v. Arizona vs. James C. "Chris" McNeil v. Court of Common Pleas of South Carolina, compared fact by fact
FactKellie Wilson v. AIM Specialty HealthScott Drake Clabourne v. ArizonaJames C. "Chris" McNeil v. Court of Common Pleas of South Carolina, Ninth Judicial Circuit, Charleston County
DocketKellie Wilson v. AIM Specialty Health26-554Scott Drake Clabourne v. Arizona26-5571James C. "Chris" McNeil v. Court of Common Pleas of South Carolina, Ninth Judicial Circuit, Charleston County26-562
StatusKellie Wilson v. AIM Specialty HealthBefore ArgumentsScott Drake Clabourne v. ArizonaBefore ArgumentsJames C. "Chris" McNeil v. Court of Common Pleas of South Carolina, Ninth Judicial Circuit, Charleston CountyBefore Arguments
DateKellie Wilson v. AIM Specialty HealthOctober Term 2026 (2026–2027)Scott Drake Clabourne v. ArizonaOctober Term 2026 (2026–2027)James C. "Chris" McNeil v. Court of Common Pleas of South Carolina, Ninth Judicial Circuit, Charleston CountyOctober Term 2026 (2026–2027)
Question presentedKellie Wilson v. AIM Specialty Health1. Whether this Court should overrule McDonnell Douglas Corp. v. Green, 411 U.S. 792 (1973). 2. Whether step three of McDonnell Douglas should require a plaintiff to disprove the employer’s proffered reasoned for an adverse employment action, when the plain language of Title VII merely requires a plaintiff to establish but-for causation.Scott Drake Clabourne v. Arizona1. Whether Arizona has ignored the Strickland prejudice prong in defaulting Mr. Clabourne’s sentencing IAC claim by requiring counsel to have filed a PCR petition before the prejudice was evident, during the pendency of Martinez litigation and in the face of a previous dismissal of PCR litigation with prejudice in the trial court. 2. Whether Arizona’s inconsistent application of its procedural default rules to successive PCR claims due to their simultaneous litigation in federal courts will render this procedural default inadequate to bar federal habeas review. 3. Whether Arizona’s creation of a non-discretionary right of review of IAC claims followed by Arizona’s appointment of inexperienced PCR counsel who provided concededly deficient representation was arbitrary and denied Mr. Clabourne Fourteenth Amendment Equal Protection under Douglas v. California.James C. "Chris" McNeil v. Court of Common Pleas of South Carolina, Ninth Judicial Circuit, Charleston CountyWhether the Due Process and Equal Protection Clauses of the Fourteenth Amendment permit a court to reserve electronic access for licensed attorneys, forcing self-represented litigants to use a paper intake that degrades the integrity of evidentiary exhibits central to their claims.
SummaryKellie Wilson v. AIM Specialty HealthKellie Wilson’s petition asks the Supreme Court to review her employment-discrimination case against AIM Specialty Health and to discard the McDonnell Douglas test or change its final step, which concerns whether a worker must disprove the employer’s stated reason for an adverse job action. She argues that Title VII requires proof that discrimination was a cause without which the action would not have happened.Scott Drake Clabourne v. ArizonaScott Drake Clabourne filed a petition asking the Supreme Court to review whether Arizona wrongly barred his claim that his sentencing lawyer was ineffective, even though he says the harm became clear too late to file earlier. He also challenges Arizona’s use of filing rules to block federal review and argues that the allegedly deficient work of his appointed post-trial lawyers denied him equal protection.James C. "Chris" McNeil v. Court of Common Pleas of South Carolina, Ninth Judicial Circuit, Charleston CountyJames C. McNeil and Meaghan Poyer filed a petition asking the Supreme Court to review a court practice they say reserves electronic filing for licensed attorneys and leaves self-represented litigants to submit paper materials that degrade important evidence. They ask whether the practice violates the Fourteenth Amendment’s guarantees of due process and equal protection.

Relationship

Shared issue
Civil Rights
Why compared
Reviewed Civil Rights tags connect these current-term public cases.

Related

Sources

  • Built from reviewed issue tags and official docket records. Status lines and questions presented come from the tracked case data.