Skip to main content

Cases compared

Tyson v. Park Meadows Healthcare and Rehabilitation Center vs. Akerlund v. Atlas Air vs. Ghosh v. New York City Housing Authority

No. 26-485No. 26-497No. 26-5403

Side by side

Tyson v. Park Meadows Healthcare and Rehabilitation Center vs. Akerlund v. Atlas Air vs. Ghosh v. New York City Housing Authority, compared fact by fact
FactNancy Tyson v. Park Meadows Healthcare and Rehabilitation Center, LLCPatrick Akerlund v. Atlas Air, Inc.Shyamal Ghosh v. New York City Housing Authority
DocketNancy Tyson v. Park Meadows Healthcare and Rehabilitation Center, LLC26-485Patrick Akerlund v. Atlas Air, Inc.26-497Shyamal Ghosh v. New York City Housing Authority26-5403
StatusNancy Tyson v. Park Meadows Healthcare and Rehabilitation Center, LLCBefore ArgumentsPatrick Akerlund v. Atlas Air, Inc.Before ArgumentsShyamal Ghosh v. New York City Housing AuthorityDismissed
DateNancy Tyson v. Park Meadows Healthcare and Rehabilitation Center, LLCOctober Term 2026 (2026–2027)Patrick Akerlund v. Atlas Air, Inc.October Term 2026 (2026–2027)Shyamal Ghosh v. New York City Housing AuthorityOctober Term 2026 (2026–2027)
Question presentedNancy Tyson v. Park Meadows Healthcare and Rehabilitation Center, LLC1. Whether a State may apply a nursing-home liability statute’s exclusive-remedy provision — which by its own terms reaches only claims “which seek[] damages” — to bar a Title III claim that seeks no damages. 2. Whether, in any event, the Supremacy Clause permits a State to apply such a statute’s exclusive-remedy and pre-suit notice provisions to bar, in their entirety, a private cause of action created by Congress under Title III of the Americans with Disabilities Act.Patrick Akerlund v. Atlas Air, Inc.Whether a court may dismiss a Title VII religious-discrimination claim at the pleading stage on the ground that an employee’s professed religious objection to a workplace requirement is in fact secular or political, notwithstanding the complaint’s allegation that the objection rested on sincerely held religious belief?Shyamal Ghosh v. New York City Housing Authority1. Whether, consistent with Thomas v. Am, 474 U.S. 140 (1985), a court of appeals may refuse to excuse a pro se litigant’s failure to object to a magistrate judge’s report and recommendation under the nonjurisdictional forfeiture rule when the record reflects health-related and communication difficulties affecting compliance with court deadlines. 2. Whether a court of appeals may treat the failure to object to a magistrate judge’s report and recommendation as a complete bar to appellate merits review of a pro se litigant’s federal employment discrimination claims, where those claims were dismissed at the pleading stage before any factual record was developed through discovery.
SummaryNancy Tyson v. Park Meadows Healthcare and Rehabilitation Center, LLCNancy Tyson asks the Supreme Court to review Florida courts’ decision to throw out her Americans with Disabilities Act claim against Park Meadows Healthcare and others under Florida’s nursing-home rules. Her claim sought only court orders and fees, not money damages; she asks whether the state can bar it without deciding whether discrimination occurred.Patrick Akerlund v. Atlas Air, Inc.Patrick Akerlund and other Atlas Air employees allege that workplace requirements conflicted with their sincerely held religious beliefs. The Eleventh Circuit upheld dismissal of their federal religious-discrimination claim before evidence was presented, saying the complaint described political or logistical objections; their petition asks the Supreme Court to review that ruling.Shyamal Ghosh v. New York City Housing AuthorityGhosh asks whether the Second Circuit could refuse to excuse his missed deadline to object to a magistrate judge’s recommendation and bar review of employment-discrimination claims against the New York City Housing Authority, dismissed before discovery. He cites health and communication difficulties; the Court distributed his petition for conference, leaving Supreme Court review unresolved.

Relationship

Shared issue
Civil Rights
Why compared
Reviewed Civil Rights tags connect these current-term public cases.

Related

Sources

  • Built from reviewed issue tags and official docket records. Status lines and questions presented come from the tracked case data.