Cases compared
National Small Business United, dba National Small Business Association v. Scott Bessent, Secretary of the Treasury vs. Texas Top Cop Shop, Incorporated v. Todd Blanche, Attorney General vs. Eric Gomez v. David Saccoccio
Criminal Procedure cases on the Supreme Court docket, side by side.
No. 25-1201No. 25-1290No. 25-1314
Side by side
| Fact | National Small Business United, dba National Small Business Association v. Scott Bessent, Secretary of the Treasury | Texas Top Cop Shop, Incorporated v. Todd Blanche, Attorney General | Eric Gomez v. David Saccoccio |
|---|---|---|---|
| Docket | 25-1201 | 25-1290 | 25-1314 |
| Status | Before Arguments | Before Arguments | Before Arguments |
| Date | October Term 2025 (2025–2026) | October Term 2025 (2025–2026) | October Term 2025 (2025–2026) |
| Question presented | 1. Whether the reporting requirements exceed Congress’s enumerated powers on their face. 2. Whether the reporting requirements violate the Fourth Amendment on their face. | 1. Whether the Act’s regulation of corporations merely because they exist under state law exceeds Congress’s Commerce Clause authority. 2. Whether the Act’s suspicionless and warrantless searches to further a generalized interest in expedient law enforcement violate the Fourth Amendment. | Whether combining general principles from two factually dissimilar cases conflicts with this Court’s precedents requiring lower courts to define rights with specificity and use close factual analogues in determining whether a Fourth Amendment constitutional right is clearly established. |
| Summary | This case challenges the Corporate Transparency Act, which requires many state-created companies to report information about their beneficial owners to the federal government. The petitioners argue that Congress exceeded its Commerce Clause power by imposing the reporting requirement on companies based solely on their existence under state law; the Eleventh Circuit upheld the law. | This case challenges the Corporate Transparency Act, which requires many corporations to report identifying information about their beneficial owners to the federal government. The petitioners argue that Congress lacked constitutional authority to impose the reporting requirement and that the required disclosure is an unreasonable search under the Fourth Amendment. | Officer Eric Gomez asks the Supreme Court to review a Ninth Circuit ruling that allowed David Saccoccio’s Fourth Amendment excessive-force claim to proceed after Gomez struck him with a less-lethal foam-projectile round while Saccoccio was fleeing, climbing a fence into a private yard, and violating a curfew. The dispute concerns whether Gomez was entitled to qualified immunity because the law allegedly did not clearly establish that his conduct was unconstitutional. |
Relationship
- Shared issue
- Criminal Procedure
- Why compared
- Reviewed Criminal Procedure tags connect these current-term public cases.
Related
Sources
- Built from reviewed issue tags and official docket records. Status lines and questions presented come from the tracked case data.