Skip to main content

Cases compared

Missionaries of Saint John the Baptist v. Joel Frederic, et ux. vs. Grand v. City of University Heights vs. Darrell Leon McClanahan, III v. Trump

No. 25-1131No. 25-965No. 26-5296

Side by side

Missionaries of Saint John the Baptist v. Joel Frederic, et ux. vs. Grand v. City of University Heights vs. Darrell Leon McClanahan, III v. Trump, compared fact by fact
FactMissionaries of Saint John the Baptist, Inc., Petitioner v. Joel Frederic, et ux.Daniel Grand, Petitioner v. City of University Heights, Ohio, et al.Darrell Leon McClanahan, III v. Donald Trump, President of the United States
DocketMissionaries of Saint John the Baptist, Inc., Petitioner v. Joel Frederic, et ux.25-1131Daniel Grand, Petitioner v. City of University Heights, Ohio, et al.25-965Darrell Leon McClanahan, III v. Donald Trump, President of the United States26-5296
StatusMissionaries of Saint John the Baptist, Inc., Petitioner v. Joel Frederic, et ux.Before ArgumentsDaniel Grand, Petitioner v. City of University Heights, Ohio, et al.Before ArgumentsDarrell Leon McClanahan, III v. Donald Trump, President of the United StatesBefore Arguments
DateMissionaries of Saint John the Baptist, Inc., Petitioner v. Joel Frederic, et ux.Argued Jan 20, 2027Daniel Grand, Petitioner v. City of University Heights, Ohio, et al.Argued Dec 9, 2026Darrell Leon McClanahan, III v. Donald Trump, President of the United StatesOctober Term 2026 (2026–2027)
Question presentedMissionaries of Saint John the Baptist, Inc., Petitioner v. Joel Frederic, et ux.1. Whether prohibiting a religious organization from constructing a religious structure on its own property imposes a substantial burden under RLUIPA. 2. Whether a zoning ordinance violates RLUIPA’s equal-terms provision by imposing express restrictions on religious assemblies that do not apply to nonreligious assemblies.Daniel Grand, Petitioner v. City of University Heights, Ohio, et al.Whether the First Amendment's established chilling-effect doctrine-under which a credible government threat that deters the exercise of fundamental rights constitutes a complete and independently actionable constitutional injury-is displaced by Williamson Cnty .'s land-use finality requirement when a plaintiff alleges that government threats both before and after a Planning Commission meeting chilled religious exercise, worship, and assembly.Darrell Leon McClanahan, III v. Donald Trump, President of the United States1. Whether a federal court may apply TransUnion LLC v. Ramirez, 594 U.S. 413 (2021), to dismiss a First Amendment pre-enforcement challenge for lack of Article III standing by requiring past or imminent enforcement, despite this Court's decisions in Susan B. Anthony List v. Driehaus, 573 U.S. 149 (2014), Babbitt v. United Farm Workers National Union, 442 U.S. 289 (1979), and Virginia v. American Booksellers Association, 484 U.S. 383 (1988), which hold that self censorship in response to a credible threat of enforcement is itself a concrete, cognizable injury. 2. Whether the Eighth Circuit's decision which treated a detailed record of governmental labeling of petitioner's speech in active federal litigation, sworn declarations of self-censorship, and the government's own characterization of this lawsuit as petitioner's demand to speak "without fear of reprisal" as "speculative" at the pleading stage can be reconciled with this Court's recognition in National Rifle Association of America v. Vullo, 602 U.S. 175 (2024), that fear of reprisal and informal government pressure leveraged to suppress disfavored speech may state a plausible First Amendment claim actionable without completed enforcement.
SummaryMissionaries of Saint John the Baptist, Inc., Petitioner v. Joel Frederic, et ux.This pending case concerns whether Kentucky land-use rules unlawfully prevented Missionaries of Saint John the Baptist from building a religious structure on its own property. The petition argues that the rules violate the Religious Land Use and Institutionalized Persons Act (RLUIPA) by substantially burdening religious exercise and by treating religious assemblies less favorably than comparable nonreligious assemblies.Daniel Grand, Petitioner v. City of University Heights, Ohio, et al.Daniel Grand alleges that University Heights officials’ threats concerning his proposed religious gatherings at his home deterred worship and assembly protected by the First Amendment. The case concerns whether he may pursue that claim even though the city had not made a final land-use decision about the gatherings.Darrell Leon McClanahan, III v. Donald Trump, President of the United StatesDarrell Leon McClanahan asks the Supreme Court to review the Eighth Circuit’s dismissal of his pre-enforcement First Amendment suit, arguing that his claimed self-censorship and fear of government reprisal give him standing (the legal right to sue) before enforcement occurs.

Relationship

Shared issue
First Amendment
Why compared
Reviewed First Amendment tags connect these current-term public cases.

Related

Sources

  • Built from reviewed issue tags and official docket records. Status lines and questions presented come from the tracked case data.