Cases compared
Kevin Isaac Montoya Palacios v. Vernon Liggins vs. Rudra v. United States vs. Stellwagen v. Florida
No. 25-1223No. 26-259No. 26-499
Side by side
| Fact | Kevin Isaac Montoya Palacios, Petitioner v. Vernon Liggins, Acting Field Office Director, Baltimore, Maryland, Immigration and Customs Enforcement, et al. | Soumya Rudra, Petitioner v. United States | Gerard F. Stellwagen, Petitioner v. Florida |
|---|---|---|---|
| Docket | Kevin Isaac Montoya Palacios, Petitioner v. Vernon Liggins, Acting Field Office Director, Baltimore, Maryland, Immigration and Customs Enforcement, et al.25-1223 | Soumya Rudra, Petitioner v. United States26-259 | Gerard F. Stellwagen, Petitioner v. Florida26-499 |
| Status | Kevin Isaac Montoya Palacios, Petitioner v. Vernon Liggins, Acting Field Office Director, Baltimore, Maryland, Immigration and Customs Enforcement, et al.Before Arguments | Soumya Rudra, Petitioner v. United StatesDismissed | Gerard F. Stellwagen, Petitioner v. FloridaBefore Arguments |
| Date | Kevin Isaac Montoya Palacios, Petitioner v. Vernon Liggins, Acting Field Office Director, Baltimore, Maryland, Immigration and Customs Enforcement, et al.Argued Jan 11, 2027 | Soumya Rudra, Petitioner v. United StatesOctober Term 2026 (2026–2027) | Gerard F. Stellwagen, Petitioner v. FloridaOctober Term 2026 (2026–2027) |
| Question presented | Kevin Isaac Montoya Palacios, Petitioner v. Vernon Liggins, Acting Field Office Director, Baltimore, Maryland, Immigration and Customs Enforcement, et al.Whether, under EAJA, "any civil action" encompasses an action seeking a writ of habeas corpus to challenge civil immigration detention? | Soumya Rudra, Petitioner v. United States1. Whether a rebuttable presumption standard of review should apply to a defendant’s appeal of his sentence challenging that the sentence is in violation of the 18 U.S.C.§3553(A)? 2. Whether U.S.S.G. §2G2.1 enhancement for use of a computer in a case involving child pornography is improper due to its inherent and nearly universal application in such cases resulting in a double counting for the same conduct? | Gerard F. Stellwagen, Petitioner v. Florida1. Staleness. Whether a single, isolated transmission of child pornography – here, one image sent roughly eight months before the warrant issued – becomes categorically “not stale” for purposes of probable cause simply because digital files are capable of indefinite storage, even where the affidavit contains no evidence that the suspect is a “collector” who retains such material. 2. Nexus to the residence. Whether evidence that an online child-pornography offense was committed through an email account associated with a suspect, without evidence tying that activity to the suspect’s home (such as an IP address for the device used), establishes the “fair probability” that evidence will be found in the home that the Fourth Amendment requires. 3. Particularity and overbreadth. Whether, in light of Riley v. California, 573 U.S. 373 (2014), the Fourth Amendment’s particularity requirement permits a warrant to authorize the seizure and forensic search of every electronic device and all data in a residence based on probable cause as to a single identified file. |
| Summary | Kevin Isaac Montoya Palacios, Petitioner v. Vernon Liggins, Acting Field Office Director, Baltimore, Maryland, Immigration and Customs Enforcement, et al.This case asks whether a person who wins a habeas corpus challenge to civil immigration detention may recover attorney’s fees and costs from the federal government under the Equal Access to Justice Act. The Court will decide whether such a habeas case counts as a “civil action” under that law. | Soumya Rudra, Petitioner v. United StatesSoumya Rudra challenged his federal sentence, questioning how appeals courts should review his sentencing claim and disputing enhancements for closely timed offenses and computer use. The Supreme Court refused to hear his case (denied review), so it did not decide those arguments. | Gerard F. Stellwagen, Petitioner v. FloridaGerard F. Stellwagen’s case against Florida is pending before the Supreme Court. The information provided does not say what the dispute is about or what action the Court has taken. |
Relationship
- Shared issue
- Criminal Procedure
- Why compared
- Reviewed Criminal Procedure tags connect these current-term public cases.
Related
Sources
- Built from reviewed issue tags and official docket records. Status lines and questions presented come from the tracked case data.