Cases compared
Kevin Isaac Montoya Palacios v. Vernon Liggins vs. Eastman v. State Bar of California vs. McDowell v. Florida
No. 25-1223No. 26-336No. 26-5886
Side by side
| Fact | Kevin Isaac Montoya Palacios v. Vernon Liggins, Acting Field Office Director, Baltimore, Maryland, Immigration and Customs Enforcement | John C. Eastman v. State Bar of California | Patrick R. McDowell v. Florida |
|---|---|---|---|
| Docket | Kevin Isaac Montoya Palacios v. Vernon Liggins, Acting Field Office Director, Baltimore, Maryland, Immigration and Customs Enforcement25-1223 | John C. Eastman v. State Bar of California26-336 | Patrick R. McDowell v. Florida26-5886 |
| Status | Kevin Isaac Montoya Palacios v. Vernon Liggins, Acting Field Office Director, Baltimore, Maryland, Immigration and Customs EnforcementBefore Arguments | John C. Eastman v. State Bar of CaliforniaBefore Arguments | Patrick R. McDowell v. FloridaBefore Arguments |
| Date | Kevin Isaac Montoya Palacios v. Vernon Liggins, Acting Field Office Director, Baltimore, Maryland, Immigration and Customs EnforcementArgued Jan 11, 2027 | John C. Eastman v. State Bar of CaliforniaOctober Term 2026 (2026–2027) | Patrick R. McDowell v. FloridaOctober Term 2026 (2026–2027) |
| Question presented | Kevin Isaac Montoya Palacios v. Vernon Liggins, Acting Field Office Director, Baltimore, Maryland, Immigration and Customs EnforcementWhether, under EAJA, "any civil action" encompasses an action seeking a writ of habeas corpus to challenge civil immigration detention? | John C. Eastman v. State Bar of California1. Whether California’s disbarment of an attorney for legal advice, public commentary, and constitutional advocacy on matters of public concern is incompatible with the First Amendment. 2. Whether California’s treatment of constitutional advocacy as a conspiracy to defraud the United States under 18 U.S.C. §371 improperly expands that criminal statute in a way that impermissibly burdens speech and petitioning activity protected by the First Amendment. 3. Whether, under this Court’s decision in In re Loney , subject matter jurisdiction to initiate discipline for allegedly false statements in a federal court filing lies exclusively with the federal tribunal. | Patrick R. McDowell v. Florida1. Whether Florida’s capital sentencing system – which does not narrow death eligibility to a small sub-class of persons convicted of first-degree murder, which does not require death unanimity of the jury’s recommendation of death, which does not review death sentences on appeal for their proportionality or relative culpability amongst co-defendants, and in which appellate review has become all but a rubber stamp – passes constitutional muster. 2. Whether the Ex Post Facto Clause forbids applying Florida’s nonunanimity rule retroactively to individuals whose crimes were committed when state law required such jury determinations to be unanimous. |
| Summary | Kevin Isaac Montoya Palacios v. Vernon Liggins, Acting Field Office Director, Baltimore, Maryland, Immigration and Customs EnforcementThis case asks whether a person who wins a habeas corpus challenge to civil immigration detention may recover attorney’s fees and costs from the federal government under the Equal Access to Justice Act. The Court will decide whether such a habeas case counts as a “civil action” under that law. | John C. Eastman v. State Bar of CaliforniaEastman asks the Supreme Court to review California’s decision to bar him from law practice over his legal advice, public comments, and constitutional advocacy. He argues the discipline violates the First Amendment, wrongly treats advocacy as a federal conspiracy, and intrudes on federal courts’ authority over alleged false statements in a federal filing. | Patrick R. McDowell v. FloridaPatrick McDowell asks the U.S. Supreme Court to review whether Florida’s capital-sentencing system is constitutional, arguing that it does not adequately limit who can receive the death penalty or meaningfully review death sentences, and permits juries to recommend death without unanimity. He also argues Florida cannot apply its nonunanimity rule to crimes committed when unanimous jury decisions were required. |
Relationship
- Shared issue
- Criminal Procedure
- Why compared
- Reviewed Criminal Procedure tags connect these current-term public cases.
Related
Sources
- Built from reviewed issue tags and official docket records. Status lines and questions presented come from the tracked case data.