Skip to main content

Cases compared

Alan Walter Colie v. Virginia vs. Becker v. United States vs. Celestine v. United States

No. 26-321No. 26-5086No. 26-5311

Side by side

Alan Walter Colie v. Virginia vs. Becker v. United States vs. Celestine v. United States, compared fact by fact
FactAlan Walter Colie v. VirginiaMackenzie Becker v. United StatesMichael Celestine v. United States
DocketAlan Walter Colie v. Virginia26-321Mackenzie Becker v. United States26-5086Michael Celestine v. United States26-5311
StatusAlan Walter Colie v. VirginiaDismissedMackenzie Becker v. United StatesDismissedMichael Celestine v. United StatesDismissed
DateAlan Walter Colie v. VirginiaOctober Term 2026 (2026–2027)Mackenzie Becker v. United StatesOctober Term 2026 (2026–2027)Michael Celestine v. United StatesOctober Term 2026 (2026–2027)
Question presentedAlan Walter Colie v. Virginia1. Does the right to self-defense meet that test, by virtue of Justice Scalia’s extensively-catalogued recognition of self-defense as an “inherent,” “ancient” and “common law” right in District of Columbia v. Heller, 554 U.S. 570 (2008), and subsequent cases? 2. If so, did the Virginia courts violate due process by effectively stopping Mr. Colie’s jury from considering self-defense, when deliberating on the only remaining allegation against him: unlawful discharge of a firearm? (After acquitting Mr. Colie of all other criminal charges on the basis of bona fide self-defense?)? 3. Does due process require vacatur of the sole conviction, consistent with Powell’s Footnote 8 exception, where the jury’s verdicts as a whole rationally convey that they found the act legally justified by self-defense, foreclosing lawful conviction?Mackenzie Becker v. United StatesWhether a search warrant’s supporting affidavit establishes probable cause to search a suspect’s home for a firearm used in a crime based solely on the inference that firearms are generally kept at home, or whether the Fourth Amendment requires case-specific facts linking the weapon sought to the residence to be searched?Michael Celestine v. United States1. Whether 18 U.S.C. § 922(g)(1)’s prohibition on mere firearm possession exceeds the scope of Congress’s power to regulate interstate and foreign commerce, both facially and applied to Mr. Celestine and, relatedly, whether this Court should revisit Scarborough v. United States, 431 U.S. 563, 575 (1977), in light of the Court’s more recent Commerce Clause precedent. 2. Whether § 922(g)(1) is unconstitutionally vague, either facially or as applied to Mr. Celestine, and, more fundamentally, whether a statute prohibiting conduct protected by the Second Amendment should be subject to facial or as-applied void-for-vagueness scrutiny. 3. Whether § 922(g)(1) is unconstitutional under the Second Amendment, either facially or as applied to Mr. Celestine.
SummaryAlan Walter Colie v. VirginiaAlan Walter Colie asks the Supreme Court to review his sole Virginia conviction for unlawful discharge of a firearm. His petition says the jury acquitted him of the other charges on self-defense grounds but was prevented from considering that defense on the remaining charge; the petition was distributed for a conference, which alone does not mean the Court agreed to hear it.Mackenzie Becker v. United StatesMackenzie Becker asks whether police may search a suspect’s home for a firearm used in a crime based only on the general idea that people keep guns at home, or whether they need facts linking the firearm to that home. The petition was distributed for a conference; that step is not itself a decision to hear the case.Michael Celestine v. United StatesMichael Celestine’s petition challenges a federal law barring certain people from possessing firearms, arguing that it exceeds Congress’s commerce power, is too vague, or violates the Second Amendment. The petition was distributed for a Supreme Court conference; that step is not a decision to hear the case.

Relationship

Shared issue
Gun Rights
Why compared
Reviewed Gun Rights tags connect these current-term public cases.

Related

Sources

  • Built from reviewed issue tags and official docket records. Status lines and questions presented come from the tracked case data.