Skip to main content

Cases compared

Apple v. Epic Games vs. Safron Capital v. Elanco Animal Health vs. Carol Ann McBratnie v. Amazon.com

No. 25-1311No. 26-127No. 26-5795

Side by side

Apple v. Epic Games vs. Safron Capital v. Elanco Animal Health vs. Carol Ann McBratnie v. Amazon.com, compared fact by fact
FactApple Inc., Petitioner v. Epic Games, Inc.Safron Capital Corporation v. Elanco Animal Health Inc.Carol Ann McBratnie v. Amazon.com, Inc.
DocketApple Inc., Petitioner v. Epic Games, Inc.25-1311Safron Capital Corporation v. Elanco Animal Health Inc.26-127Carol Ann McBratnie v. Amazon.com, Inc.26-5795
StatusApple Inc., Petitioner v. Epic Games, Inc.Before ArgumentsSafron Capital Corporation v. Elanco Animal Health Inc.DismissedCarol Ann McBratnie v. Amazon.com, Inc.Dismissed
DateApple Inc., Petitioner v. Epic Games, Inc.Argued Jan 11, 2027Safron Capital Corporation v. Elanco Animal Health Inc.October Term 2026 (2026–2027)Carol Ann McBratnie v. Amazon.com, Inc.October Term 2026 (2026–2027)
Question presentedApple Inc., Petitioner v. Epic Games, Inc.1. Whether a court may hold a party in civil contempt based on a violation of an injunction's "spirit" where the injunction is silent as to the conduct upon which contempt is based, as the Ninth Circuit holds; or, instead, whether a court must ground a finding of civil contempt on the violation of an order that clearly and unambiguously proscribes the precise conduct at issue, as other circuits hold. 2. Whether the Ninth Circuit has properly created an "antitrust" or "competition" exception to Trump v. CASA, Inc ., 606 U.S. 831 (2025), and the longstanding equitable principles on which CASA rests, or otherwise disregarded CASA 's limits.Safron Capital Corporation v. Elanco Animal Health Inc.When, if ever, can the issue of materiality in an action alleging violations of the federal securities laws be determined by a court as a matter of law without findings of fact by the trier of fact?Carol Ann McBratnie v. Amazon.com, Inc.1. Did the US District Court lack jurisdiction to compel arbitration under both the FAA and the Delaware Uniform Arbitration Act (exclusive jurisdiction)? 2. Where, when and by whom should challenges to the legality of a contract be addressed, when arbitration is involved, where ‘ gateway ’ decisions are assigned to the Court, where severing of illegal clauses is contractually anticipated? The sub-question is 'If misclassifying workers to thwart the FLSA, would be an illegal unenforceable contract?
SummaryApple Inc., Petitioner v. Epic Games, Inc.The Court will consider whether Apple could be held in civil contempt for conduct that allegedly violated the “spirit” of an injunction in its dispute with Epic Games, even though the injunction did not expressly prohibit that conduct. It will also consider whether the Ninth Circuit could uphold relief extending beyond the parties under an asserted antitrust or competition-law exception to limits on federal courts’ equitable power.Safron Capital Corporation v. Elanco Animal Health Inc.Safron Capital and its co-petitioners ask when a court may decide whether information was important to investors in a federal securities-law case without a factfinder deciding that issue. The petition has been distributed for a Supreme Court conference, but that is not a decision to hear the case.Carol Ann McBratnie v. Amazon.com, Inc.Carol Ann McBratnie asks the Supreme Court to review whether a federal district court could order arbitration under federal and Delaware law, and who should decide her challenge to the contract, including whether alleged worker misclassification to avoid the Fair Labor Standards Act makes it illegal. Her petition was sent to a conference; that is not a decision to hear the case.

Relationship

Shared issue
Business and Regulation
Why compared
Reviewed Business and Regulation tags connect these current-term public cases.

Related

Sources

  • Built from reviewed issue tags and official docket records. Status lines and questions presented come from the tracked case data.