Skip to main content

Emergency application

Union rights for immigration judges

Daren K. Margolin, Director of the Executive Office for Immigration Review v. National Association of Immigration Judges

Denied
No. 25A662Stay applicationFiled by a private partyPresented to The Chief JusticeFrom United States Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit

What did the Court do?

The Court denied the request on December 19, 2025: the lower court's ruling stays in effect while the appeal continues.

Emergency rulings are temporary and do not decide the underlying case.

Filed Ruled 14 days after filing

What's being asked

Daren K. Margolin, director of the federal office overseeing immigration judges, asks the Supreme Court to pause the Fourth Circuit’s ruling from taking effect. The government plans to ask the Supreme Court to hear the case. The National Association of Immigration Judges challenges a policy requiring immigration judges to get permission before public speech about immigration. The association says the policy violates its members’ First and Fifth Amendment rights. The district court threw the case out; the Fourth Circuit wiped out (vacated) that ruling and sent the case back (remanded).

What the Court did

The Court refused emergency help and denied the stay (a temporary pause); it said the government had not shown irreparable harm at this stage. The government may reapply if district-court discovery begins before the Court decides its forthcoming petition asking it to hear the case. The Chief Justice’s earlier stay was wiped out (vacated); the Court did not publish the justices’ votes.

Vote not published · 9the order does not say how they voted
  1. Roberts
  2. Thomas
  3. Alito
  4. Sotomayor
  5. Kagan
  6. Gorsuch
  7. Kavanaugh
  8. Barrett
  9. Jackson
The order does not say how any justice voted, as is usual on the emergency docket.
Half of 83 rulings on applications where the Court asked for a response came 12 to 26 days after filing, and the median was 17 days; this one was ruled on 14 days after filing.

What it means

The Court’s emergency decision addresses only a temporary pause; it does not decide who wins the speech-policy dispute. The case remains in the district court, where discovery could begin. No related Supreme Court case on the main question is listed, and the application was not set for argument.

Sources

Facts on this page come from the Supreme Court docket, orders, and opinions for No. 25A662. The answers restate that record in plain words; explainer copy is written from the record and the filings only.

Checked October 3, 2026