Skip to main content

Emergency application · Capital case

Right to a lawyer

Tony Carruthers v. Tennessee

Denied
No. 25A1255Stay applicationFiled by a prisoner facing executionPresented to Justice KavanaughFrom Supreme Court of Tennessee, Western Division

What did the Court do?

The Court denied the request on May 19, 2026 and refused to halt the execution.

Emergency rulings are temporary and do not decide the underlying case.

Filed Ruled 6 days after filing

What's being asked

Tony Carruthers, a Tennessee prisoner under a death sentence, asks the Supreme Court to pause his execution, scheduled for May 21. He asks for the pause while the Court considers his petition for Supreme Court review. Carruthers says he was forced to represent himself at trial, where he was convicted of three first-degree murders. The Tennessee Supreme Court denied his earlier request to pause the execution.

What the Court did

The Court refused to pause Carruthers's execution and denied his stay request. It also denied his petition for certiorari (a request for Supreme Court review), refusing to hear the case. The order gives no reasons, and the Court did not publish how the justices voted.

Vote not published · 9the order does not say how they voted
  1. Roberts
  2. Thomas
  3. Alito
  4. Sotomayor
  5. Kagan
  6. Gorsuch
  7. Kavanaugh
  8. Barrett
  9. Jackson
The order does not say how any justice voted, as is usual on the emergency docket.
Half of 92 rulings on capital applications decided without a response came 2 to 5 days after filing, and the median was 3 days; this one was ruled on 6 days after filing.

What it means

The refusal to pause the execution does not decide whether Carruthers's claim about being forced to represent himself is correct. The Court also refused Supreme Court review, leaving the Tennessee Supreme Court's ruling in place. No related case is listed, and no argument was set.

Sources

Facts on this page come from the Supreme Court docket, orders, and opinions for No. 25A1255. The answers restate that record in plain words; explainer copy is written from the record and the filings only.

Checked October 4, 2026