Cases compared
Havlish v. Taliban vs. Coleman v. Merit Systems Protection Board vs. Meidinger v. Commissioner of Internal Revenue
No. 26-292No. 26-427No. 26-598
Side by side
| Fact | Fiona Havlish v. The Taliban | Richard W. Coleman, Jr. v. Merit Systems Protection Board | Roy J. Meidinger, Sr. v. Commissioner of Internal Revenue |
|---|---|---|---|
| Docket | Fiona Havlish v. The Taliban26-292 | Richard W. Coleman, Jr. v. Merit Systems Protection Board26-427 | Roy J. Meidinger, Sr. v. Commissioner of Internal Revenue26-598 |
| Status | Fiona Havlish v. The TalibanBefore Arguments | Richard W. Coleman, Jr. v. Merit Systems Protection BoardDismissed | Roy J. Meidinger, Sr. v. Commissioner of Internal RevenueBefore Arguments |
| Date | Fiona Havlish v. The TalibanOctober Term 2026 (2026–2027) | Richard W. Coleman, Jr. v. Merit Systems Protection BoardOctober Term 2026 (2026–2027) | Roy J. Meidinger, Sr. v. Commissioner of Internal RevenueOctober Term 2026 (2026–2027) |
| Question presented | Fiona Havlish v. The TalibanUnder the Terrorism Risk Insurance Act, does a plaintiff’s right to execute on blocked assets depend on whether the assets’ owner was a terrorist party or its agency or instrumentality at the time the assets were blocked? | Richard W. Coleman, Jr. v. Merit Systems Protection Board1. Whether the Federal Circuit and the Merit Systems Protection Board erred in dismissing an Individual Right of Action appeal for lack of jurisdiction where the employee’s disclosures raised a nonfrivolous allegation that the agency continued to rely on a position description containing a duplicated electronic signature — described by the agency itself as “sloppy work” yet never corrected — and that such continued reliance, together with the refusal to correct material inaccuracies in the document, evidenced a potential violation of 18 U. S. C. § 1001(a)(3) or an abuse of authority under 5 U. S. C. § 2302(b)(8). 2. Whether repeated post-disclosure refusals by a federal agency to reinstate hazardous duty pay or to correct a defective official position description constitute independent “failures to take” a personnel action under the plain meaning of 5 U. S. C. §§2302(a)(2)(A)(ix) and (b)(8), sufficient to support Merit Systems Protection Board jurisdiction over an Individual Right of Action appeal. 3. Whether the MSPB’s dismissal of an IRA appeal for failure to nonfrivolously allege that protected disclosures were a contributing factor may stand when the disclosures concern the agency’s systematic refusal to correct a position description that is factually contradictory on its face regarding hazardous duties (including CBRN and explosives exposure requirements) and that serves as the basis for the ongoing denial of hazardous duty pay under 5 U. S. C. § 5545(d) and 5 C. F. R., pt. 550, subpt. I. | Roy J. Meidinger, Sr. v. Commissioner of Internal Revenue1. Whether a final determination by the IRS Whistleblower Office denying or rejecting an award on the ground that no proceeds were collected constitutes a reviewable determination under 26 U.S.C. § 7623(b)(4)? 2. Whether the Tax Court may dismiss for lack of jurisdiction without reviewing the administrative record or applying the APA, 5 U.S.C. § 706? 3. Whether agency inaction or no action or action on wrong parties may defeat statutory whistleblower rights? 4. Whether courts must identify evidence supporting jurisdictional dismissals of Lack of Subject Matter Jurisdiction? |
| Summary | Fiona Havlish v. The TalibanFamilies of victims of the September 11 attacks and other terrorist attacks seek to collect court judgments from blocked assets under the Terrorism Risk Insurance Act. The Second Circuit ruled that the assets qualify only if their owner was a terrorist party’s agency or instrumentality when they were blocked; the Supreme Court petition is pending. | Richard W. Coleman, Jr. v. Merit Systems Protection BoardColeman seeks Supreme Court review of the Federal Circuit and Merit Systems Protection Board’s decision throwing out his appeal, arguing that disclosures about a job description’s duplicate electronic signature and agency refusals to correct it or restore hazardous-duty pay should have let it proceed. Conference distribution does not mean the Court agreed to hear it. | Roy J. Meidinger, Sr. v. Commissioner of Internal RevenueRoy J. Meidinger asks whether the IRS Whistleblower Office’s rejection of his whistleblower-award claim because no proceeds were collected can be reviewed, and whether the Tax Court could throw out his challenge without reviewing the agency record or following the Administrative Procedure Act’s review rules. He has filed a petition asking the Supreme Court to hear the case. |
Relationship
- Shared issue
- Administrative Law
- Why compared
- Reviewed Administrative Law tags connect these current-term public cases.
Related
Sources
- Built from reviewed issue tags and official docket records. Status lines and questions presented come from the tracked case data.