Skip to main content

Cases compared

Republican National Committee v. Mi Familia Vota vs. Perez-Otero v. United States

No. 25-1017No. 26-6171

Side by side

Republican National Committee v. Mi Familia Vota vs. Perez-Otero v. United States, compared fact by fact
FactRepublican National Committee v. Mi Familia VotaAngel Perez-Otero, Petitioner v. United States
DocketRepublican National Committee v. Mi Familia Vota25-1017Angel Perez-Otero, Petitioner v. United States26-6171
StatusRepublican National Committee v. Mi Familia VotaBefore ArgumentsAngel Perez-Otero, Petitioner v. United StatesBefore Arguments
DateRepublican National Committee v. Mi Familia VotaArgued Dec 8, 2026Angel Perez-Otero, Petitioner v. United StatesOctober Term 2026 (2026–2027)
Question presentedRepublican National Committee v. Mi Familia Vota1. Does the National Voter Registration Act or a federal consent decree prohibit Arizona from requiring voter-registration applicants to produce "satisfactory evidence" of U.S. citizenship when registering with a state registration form? 2. Does the National Voter Registration Act prohibit Arizona from implementing a program within 90 days of a federal election to cancel the registrations of voters who are not U.S. citizens?Angel Perez-Otero, Petitioner v. United States1. Whether the McCormick’s holding is disregarded when prosecutors are allowed to manipulate the allegations, in an indictment, to avoid complying with it. 2. Whether after McCormick , in cases where political campaign contributions are charged as bribery and extortion, evidence of the donor’s intention of gaining access to politicians by making said political campaign contributions, is insufficient to prove the charges. 3. Whether evidence of payments of political campaign contributions at trial, that were not included in the allegations of the indictment, is a prejudicial variance. 4. Whether the District Court erred by instructing the jury that the defendant intended the payments to be bribes and extortions, and not political campaign contributions, in the absence of evidence regarding defendant’s intentions. 5. Whether after Tsarnaev , when confronted with a situation in which two jurors failed to disclose an unfavorable bias against the defendant, which resulted in their removal from the jury, the District Court had to conduct a specific and individual inquiry on the matter of bias with the remaining jurors to assure that there were no other biased jurors.
SummaryRepublican National Committee v. Mi Familia VotaThis pending case concerns Arizona laws requiring people who use the state voter-registration form to provide documentary proof of U.S. citizenship and directing officials to cancel registrations when information confirms that a registrant is not a citizen. The Court will decide whether federal voter-registration law or a prior consent decree blocks those measures, including cancellations made within 90 days of a federal election.Angel Perez-Otero, Petitioner v. United StatesAngel Perez-Otero asks the Supreme Court to review his federal case, in which prosecutors charged political campaign contributions as bribery and extortion. He challenges the indictment, the evidence and jury instructions about his intent, and the trial judge’s response after two jurors were removed for failing to disclose bias.

Relationship

Shared issue
Elections
Why compared
Reviewed Elections tags connect these current-term public cases.

Related

Sources

  • Built from reviewed issue tags and official docket records. Status lines and questions presented come from the tracked case data.