Cases compared
Reyes v. Florida A&M University Board of Trustees vs. James C. "Chris" McNeil v. Court of Common Pleas of South Carolina vs. Overton v. Florida
No. 26-448No. 26-562No. 26-6154
Side by side
| Fact | Maritza Reyes v. Florida A&M University Board of Trustees | James C. "Chris" McNeil v. Court of Common Pleas of South Carolina, Ninth Judicial Circuit, Charleston County | Thomas M. Overton v. Florida |
|---|---|---|---|
| Docket | Maritza Reyes v. Florida A&M University Board of Trustees26-448 | James C. "Chris" McNeil v. Court of Common Pleas of South Carolina, Ninth Judicial Circuit, Charleston County26-562 | Thomas M. Overton v. Florida26-6154 |
| Status | Maritza Reyes v. Florida A&M University Board of TrusteesBefore Arguments | James C. "Chris" McNeil v. Court of Common Pleas of South Carolina, Ninth Judicial Circuit, Charleston CountyBefore Arguments | Thomas M. Overton v. FloridaBefore Arguments |
| Date | Maritza Reyes v. Florida A&M University Board of TrusteesOctober Term 2026 (2026–2027) | James C. "Chris" McNeil v. Court of Common Pleas of South Carolina, Ninth Judicial Circuit, Charleston CountyOctober Term 2026 (2026–2027) | Thomas M. Overton v. FloridaOctober Term 2026 (2026–2027) |
| Question presented | Maritza Reyes v. Florida A&M University Board of Trustees1. Whether the McDonnell Douglas framework “remains a workable and useful evidentiary tool” “for evaluating Title VII claims at summary judgment” as Justice Thomas joined by Justice Gorsuch questioned in Hittle v. City of Stockton, 145 S. Ct. 759, 764 (2025) and in Ames v. Ohio Dep’t of Youth Servs., 605 U.S. 303, 326 (2025). 2. Whether the district court and the court of appeals abused their discretion by not allowing Petitioner to submit a corrected, complete response to Respondent’s motion for summary judgment with citations to her record evidence, which was timely filed in the district court, when the reason for Petitioner’s inability to submit a complete response by the deadline was due to “good cause” and “excusable neglect,” namely unforeseen, sudden illness. 3. Whether a pro se party or attorney who asserts that she could not file a complete response to a motion for summary judgment by the deadline due to sudden illness does not demonstrate that she acted diligently, per se, because she received three (3) prior “good cause” extensions (of a total of 18 days). | James C. "Chris" McNeil v. Court of Common Pleas of South Carolina, Ninth Judicial Circuit, Charleston CountyWhether the Due Process and Equal Protection Clauses of the Fourteenth Amendment permit a court to reserve electronic access for licensed attorneys, forcing self-represented litigants to use a paper intake that degrades the integrity of evidentiary exhibits central to their claims. | Thomas M. Overton v. Florida1. When an executive with unfettered discretion to grant the mercy of clemency to a death-sentenced individual and decide who lives and who dies when signing a death warrant has stated unequivocally that he would never grant clemency to anyone convicted of murder, has the clemency process in Florida been rendered a sham and violative of due process and equal protection? 2. When a death-sentenced individual attempts to raise a claim that the clemency process in Florida is a sham and clemency a legal impossibility in violation of due process and equal protection and is prevented from accessing records that would support his claim by the executive who has unfettered discretion to determine when he dies, has the secrecy of the clemency and warrant process led to executive overreach and violated his right to access to the courts? |
| Summary | Maritza Reyes v. Florida A&M University Board of TrusteesMaritza Reyes asks the Supreme Court to review her Title VII workplace-discrimination case against the Florida A&M University Board of Trustees. She challenges the lower courts’ refusal to accept her corrected response to the Board’s request to end the case without trial (summary judgment), saying sudden illness kept her from completing it, and questions whether the McDonnell Douglas framework remains useful. | James C. "Chris" McNeil v. Court of Common Pleas of South Carolina, Ninth Judicial Circuit, Charleston CountyJames C. McNeil and Meaghan Poyer filed a petition asking the Supreme Court to review a court practice they say reserves electronic filing for licensed attorneys and leaves self-represented litigants to submit paper materials that degrade important evidence. They ask whether the practice violates the Fourteenth Amendment’s guarantees of due process and equal protection. | Thomas M. Overton v. FloridaThomas Overton asks the U.S. Supreme Court to review his claims that Florida’s clemency process is unfair because the governor has said he would never grant clemency to anyone convicted of murder, and that secrecy has blocked his access to records needed to challenge the process. Overton says these practices violate due process, equal protection, and his right to access the courts. |
Relationship
- Shared issue
- Civil Rights
- Why compared
- Reviewed Civil Rights tags connect these current-term public cases.
Related
Sources
- Built from reviewed issue tags and official docket records. Status lines and questions presented come from the tracked case data.