Skip to main content

Cases compared

Reyes v. Florida A&M University Board of Trustees vs. Brannberg v. Cimino vs. Tyson v. Park Meadows Healthcare and Rehabilitation Center

No. 26-448No. 26-480No. 26-485

Side by side

Reyes v. Florida A&M University Board of Trustees vs. Brannberg v. Cimino vs. Tyson v. Park Meadows Healthcare and Rehabilitation Center, compared fact by fact
FactMaritza Reyes v. Florida A&M University Board of TrusteesJudy A. Brannberg v. John A. CiminoNancy Tyson v. Park Meadows Healthcare and Rehabilitation Center, LLC
DocketMaritza Reyes v. Florida A&M University Board of Trustees26-448Judy A. Brannberg v. John A. Cimino26-480Nancy Tyson v. Park Meadows Healthcare and Rehabilitation Center, LLC26-485
StatusMaritza Reyes v. Florida A&M University Board of TrusteesBefore ArgumentsJudy A. Brannberg v. John A. CiminoBefore ArgumentsNancy Tyson v. Park Meadows Healthcare and Rehabilitation Center, LLCBefore Arguments
DateMaritza Reyes v. Florida A&M University Board of TrusteesOctober Term 2026 (2026–2027)Judy A. Brannberg v. John A. CiminoOctober Term 2026 (2026–2027)Nancy Tyson v. Park Meadows Healthcare and Rehabilitation Center, LLCOctober Term 2026 (2026–2027)
Question presentedMaritza Reyes v. Florida A&M University Board of Trustees1. Whether the McDonnell Douglas framework “remains a workable and useful evidentiary tool” “for evaluating Title VII claims at summary judgment” as Justice Thomas joined by Justice Gorsuch questioned in Hittle v. City of Stockton, 145 S. Ct. 759, 764 (2025) and in Ames v. Ohio Dep’t of Youth Servs., 605 U.S. 303, 326 (2025). 2. Whether the district court and the court of appeals abused their discretion by not allowing Petitioner to submit a corrected, complete response to Respondent’s motion for summary judgment with citations to her record evidence, which was timely filed in the district court, when the reason for Petitioner’s inability to submit a complete response by the deadline was due to “good cause” and “excusable neglect,” namely unforeseen, sudden illness. 3. Whether a pro se party or attorney who asserts that she could not file a complete response to a motion for summary judgment by the deadline due to sudden illness does not demonstrate that she acted diligently, per se, because she received three (3) prior “good cause” extensions (of a total of 18 days).Judy A. Brannberg v. John A. Cimino1. Whether the “finality” clause in C.R.S. § 22-30.5-108(3)(d), which bars judicial review of charter school application denials, violates the First and Fourteenth Amendments when those denials resulted from constitutional violations. 2. Whether a state civil rights agency (CCRD) violates the First and Fourteenth Amendments by refusing to assert jurisdiction over third-party religious employment discrimination and retaliation claims by the Authorizer in charter school applications, in direct conflict with binding EEOC policy and federal precedent. 3. Whether Colorado’s unreviewable attorney regulation—under which the Colorado Supreme Court Office of Attorney Regulation Counsel (“OARC”) decisions are final and non-appealable under Chessin v. OARC, 2020 CO 9—shields attorney misconduct, RICO, fraud, forgery, bribery, sabotage of counsel, religious discrimination, and Unauthorized Practice of Law by a disbarred attorney from discipline, thereby violating First and Fourteenth Amendments.Nancy Tyson v. Park Meadows Healthcare and Rehabilitation Center, LLC1. Whether a State may apply a nursing-home liability statute’s exclusive-remedy provision — which by its own terms reaches only claims “which seek[] damages” — to bar a Title III claim that seeks no damages. 2. Whether, in any event, the Supremacy Clause permits a State to apply such a statute’s exclusive-remedy and pre-suit notice provisions to bar, in their entirety, a private cause of action created by Congress under Title III of the Americans with Disabilities Act.
SummaryMaritza Reyes v. Florida A&M University Board of TrusteesMaritza Reyes asks the Supreme Court to review her Title VII workplace-discrimination case against the Florida A&M University Board of Trustees. She challenges the lower courts’ refusal to accept her corrected response to the Board’s request to end the case without trial (summary judgment), saying sudden illness kept her from completing it, and questions whether the McDonnell Douglas framework remains useful.Judy A. Brannberg v. John A. CiminoJudy A. Brannberg has asked the Supreme Court to review Colorado’s bar on court challenges to charter-school application denials, a state civil-rights agency’s refusal to consider religious-employment discrimination and retaliation claims, and limits on review of attorney-discipline decisions. She argues these rules violate the First and Fourteenth Amendments and that the attorney-regulation system leaves alleged misconduct beyond discipline.Nancy Tyson v. Park Meadows Healthcare and Rehabilitation Center, LLCNancy Tyson asks the Supreme Court to review Florida courts’ decision to throw out her Americans with Disabilities Act claim against Park Meadows Healthcare and others under Florida’s nursing-home rules. Her claim sought only court orders and fees, not money damages; she asks whether the state can bar it without deciding whether discrimination occurred.

Relationship

Shared issue
Civil Rights
Why compared
Reviewed Civil Rights tags connect these current-term public cases.

Related

Sources

  • Built from reviewed issue tags and official docket records. Status lines and questions presented come from the tracked case data.