Skip to main content

Cases compared

Little v. United States vs. Carol Ann McBratnie v. Amazon.com vs. Meidinger v. Commissioner of Internal Revenue

No. 26-511No. 26-5795No. 26-598

Side by side

Little v. United States vs. Carol Ann McBratnie v. Amazon.com vs. Meidinger v. Commissioner of Internal Revenue, compared fact by fact
FactMichael Little v. United StatesCarol Ann McBratnie v. Amazon.com, Inc.Roy J. Meidinger, Sr. v. Commissioner of Internal Revenue
DocketMichael Little v. United States26-511Carol Ann McBratnie v. Amazon.com, Inc.26-5795Roy J. Meidinger, Sr. v. Commissioner of Internal Revenue26-598
StatusMichael Little v. United StatesDismissedCarol Ann McBratnie v. Amazon.com, Inc.DismissedRoy J. Meidinger, Sr. v. Commissioner of Internal RevenueBefore Arguments
DateMichael Little v. United StatesOctober Term 2026 (2026–2027)Carol Ann McBratnie v. Amazon.com, Inc.October Term 2026 (2026–2027)Roy J. Meidinger, Sr. v. Commissioner of Internal RevenueOctober Term 2026 (2026–2027)
Question presentedMichael Little v. United States1. Whether a writ of error coram nobis is available to challenge a criminal restitution order after the petitioner’s sentence has been fully served, an issue this Court has not resolved and on which the courts of appeals are divided. 2. Whether 26 U.S.C. § 6201(a)(4)(A) authorizes the Internal Revenue Service to assess and collect criminal restitution for a tax-related offense under Title 18 as an avenue independent of the sentencing court’s restitution order—and, if so, whether a restitution order calculated without accounting for that independent assessment authority may result in duplicative recovery for the same tax loss, in light of the Seventh Circuit’s intervening decision in Daugerdas v. Commissioner of Internal Revenue, No. 25-1055 (7th Cir. Mar. 30, 2026), which conflicts with the premise underlying the decision below.Carol Ann McBratnie v. Amazon.com, Inc.1. Did the US District Court lack jurisdiction to compel arbitration under both the FAA and the Delaware Uniform Arbitration Act (exclusive jurisdiction)? 2. Where, when and by whom should challenges to the legality of a contract be addressed, when arbitration is involved, where ‘ gateway ’ decisions are assigned to the Court, where severing of illegal clauses is contractually anticipated? The sub-question is 'If misclassifying workers to thwart the FLSA, would be an illegal unenforceable contract?Roy J. Meidinger, Sr. v. Commissioner of Internal Revenue1. Whether a final determination by the IRS Whistleblower Office denying or rejecting an award on the ground that no proceeds were collected constitutes a reviewable determination under 26 U.S.C. § 7623(b)(4)? 2. Whether the Tax Court may dismiss for lack of jurisdiction without reviewing the administrative record or applying the APA, 5 U.S.C. § 706? 3. Whether agency inaction or no action or action on wrong parties may defeat statutory whistleblower rights? 4. Whether courts must identify evidence supporting jurisdictional dismissals of Lack of Subject Matter Jurisdiction?
SummaryMichael Little v. United StatesMichael Little asks whether he may challenge a criminal restitution order after serving his sentence and whether the IRS may separately collect restitution for a tax offense, potentially recovering the same tax loss twice. The Supreme Court has sent his petition for conference consideration but has not agreed to hear the case.Carol Ann McBratnie v. Amazon.com, Inc.Carol Ann McBratnie asks the Supreme Court to review whether a federal district court could order arbitration under federal and Delaware law, and who should decide her challenge to the contract, including whether alleged worker misclassification to avoid the Fair Labor Standards Act makes it illegal. Her petition was sent to a conference; that is not a decision to hear the case.Roy J. Meidinger, Sr. v. Commissioner of Internal RevenueRoy J. Meidinger asks whether the IRS Whistleblower Office’s rejection of his whistleblower-award claim because no proceeds were collected can be reviewed, and whether the Tax Court could throw out his challenge without reviewing the agency record or following the Administrative Procedure Act’s review rules. He has filed a petition asking the Supreme Court to hear the case.

Relationship

Shared issue
Business and Regulation
Why compared
Reviewed Business and Regulation tags connect these current-term public cases.

Related

Sources

  • Built from reviewed issue tags and official docket records. Status lines and questions presented come from the tracked case data.