Skip to main content

Wedding cake and free speech

Masterpiece Cakeshop v. Colorado Civil Rights Comm'n

Updated Oct 21, 2026

In brief

The Supreme Court overturned the state appeals court's ruling and ruled for Phillips on his religious-exercise claim.

Where it stands
Decided

Decided 7-2 · June 4, 2018 · Opinion by Justice Kagan

What it’s about
Jack Phillips, owner of Masterpiece Cakeshop, refused to make a wedding cake for Charlie Craig and David Mullins because of his religious beliefs.
Who it affects
The decision found that the Colorado Civil Rights Commission violated Jack Phillips's First Amendment right to practice his religion in this case.

Summary: written with AI from the case record.

Illustration for Masterpiece Cakeshop, Ltd. v. Colorado Civil Rights Comm'n
Conceptual illustration · AI-generated

What it's about

The Supreme Court overturned the Colorado Court of Appeals’ ruling, deciding that the Colorado Civil Rights Commission’s hostile treatment of Phillips’s religious beliefs violated the First Amendment’s protection for religious exercise.

The case involved Colorado's law for businesses open to the public and First Amendment protection for religious practice.

Question presented

Whether applying Colorado’s public-accommodations law to compel a cake maker to create a custom wedding cake expressing a message with which the cake maker disagrees violates the Free Speech or Free Exercise Clauses of the First Amendment?

What the Court decided

Holding

The Commission’s actions in this case violated the Free Exercise Clause. 370 P. 3d 272, reversed.

Result
Reversed

The Court's reasoning

The Court decided the Commission's actions violated Phillips's First Amendment right to practice his religion (the Free Exercise Clause). Justice Kagan, who signed on to the Court's opinion, said the Commission failed to consider his religious views neutrally and respectfully.

The vote

  • Joined the judgment
  • Concurred in a separate opinion
  • Dissented
  • Wrote an opinion
Majority · 6joined the Court's opinion
  1. Breyer
  2. Kaganwrote the opinion
  3. Kennedyalso wrote separately
  4. Roberts
  5. Gorsuchalso wrote separately
  6. Alito
Concurring · 1agreed with the result, wrote separately
  1. Thomaswrote separately
Dissenting · 2disagreed with the result
  1. Ginsburgwrote the dissent
  2. Sotomayor
7 justices joined the judgment (1 writing separately), 2 dissented.

From the opinions

“As JUSTICE THOMAS observes, the Court does not hold that wedding cakes are speech or expression entitled to First Amendment protection.”

— Justice Ginsburg(dissent)

What's next

The Supreme Court has issued its decision. No further step for Colorado's courts or the parties is specified.

Documents

3

Docket activity

13
  • New analysis added

    Oct 21, 2026 · Court records

  • AI analysis generated: Impact Analysis

    Oct 21, 2026 · Generated

  • AI analysis generated: Opinion Summary

    Oct 21, 2026 · Generated

  • New analysis added

    Oct 18, 2026 · Court records

  • AI analysis generated: Case Briefing

    Oct 18, 2026 · Generated

Show 7 more
  • AI analysis generated: Decision Record

    Oct 18, 2026 · Generated

  • New analysis added

    Oct 18, 2026 · Court records

  • New analysis added

    Oct 18, 2026 · Court records

  • Case data updated: summary, question_presented, generation_metadata

    Oct 18, 2026 · Court records

  • Case data updated: question_presented, extraction_metadata

    Oct 18, 2026 · Court records

  • Opinion added: Opinion

    Jun 4, 2018 · Court records

  • Opinion added: opinion

    Jun 4, 2018 · Court records

Older entries are on the full docket.

More questions

1
Did the Court decide whether a wedding cake is protected speech?
Justice Thomas said the Court did not address Phillips's free-speech claim because it had uncertainties about the record.

Sources

Primary materials plus reporting. Best-effort analysis: this explainer relies on a mix of primary materials and trusted secondary sources. Official filings and opinions remain authoritative.

Checked Oct 18, 2026Methodology

Court records and filings

Reporting and analysis