Recovering spent health plan money
Montanile v. Board of Trustees of the National Elevator Industry Health Benefit Plan
In brief
The Supreme Court overturned the Eleventh Circuit: a plan cannot collect from a participant’s separate assets if the participant has wholly spent the settlement on items that cannot be traced.
- Where it stands
- Decided
Decided 8-1 · January 20, 2016 · Opinion by Justice Thomas
- What it’s about
- The National Elevator Industry Health Benefit Plan sought repayment from Robert Montanile’s car-accident settlement after paying his medical bills.
- Who it affects
- An ERISA benefit plan cannot collect from a participant’s separate assets if the participant has wholly spent the settlement on items that cannot be traced.
Summary: written with AI from the case record.
What it's about
The Supreme Court ruled that if Montanile had wholly spent the settlement on items that could not be traced, the plan could not collect from his separate assets; it overturned the Eleventh Circuit’s ruling and sent the case back to the lower court (remanded).
This case concerned ERISA, a federal law for employee benefit plans, and the kinds of court-ordered repayment those plans can seek.
Question presented
For purposes of the Employee Retirement Income Security Act of 1974, is a reimbursement to an employee welfare benefit plan “appropriate equitable relief” if the identified source of the reimbursement has already been spent or disbursed?
What the Court decided
Holding
When an ERISA-plan participant wholly dissipates a third-party settlement on nontraceable items, the plan fiduciary may not bring suit under §502(a)(3) to attach the participant’s separate assets. 903, reversed and remanded.
- Result
- Reversed
The vote
From the opinions
“He can escape that reimbursement obligation, the Court decides, by spending the settlement funds rapidly on nontraceable items.”
What's next
The case returns to the Eleventh Circuit for further proceedings under the Supreme Court’s ruling.
Documents
Opinions
Docket activity
New analysis added
AI analysis generated: Case Briefing
New analysis added
AI analysis generated: Impact Analysis
AI analysis generated: Opinion Summary
Show 4 moreShow fewer
AI analysis generated: Decision Record
Case data updated: summary, question_presented, generation_metadata
Case data updated: question_presented, extraction_metadata
Opinion added: Montanile
More questions
- How much did Montanile pledge to repay?
- Justice Ginsburg’s separate opinion says he pledged to reimburse the plan for at least $121,044.02 in medical expenses from a $500,000 settlement.
Sources
Primary materials plus reporting. Best-effort analysis: this explainer relies on a mix of primary materials and trusted secondary sources. Official filings and opinions remain authoritative.