Skip to main content

No. 20-1088October Term 2020Decided Jun 21, 2022

Docket 20-1088October Term 2020 (2020–2021)

Carson v. Makin

The Court is being asked whether a state can fund private schooling choices while denying families the option of religious schools.

Case status

Current stage
Decided
Latest event
Decision released Jun 21, 2022
Case Accepted
Arguments
Decision ReleasedJun 21, 2022
What it's about

This case is about Maine’s tuition-assistance program for families in school districts without their own public secondary schools and whether the state can exclude schools that provide religious instruction from that program. The dispute asks whether Maine may offer generally available school aid while denying families the option to use it at religious schools.

Question presented

Does a state violate the Religion Clauses or Equal Protection Clause of the United States Constitution by prohibiting students participating in an otherwise generally available student-aid program from choosing to use their aid to attend schools that provide religious, or "sectarian," instruction?

Case path

United States Court of Appeals for the First Circuit / Decision released Jun 21, 2022

Area

Civil Rights

Briefing

What it's about

The case asks whether Maine can bar families from using public tuition assistance at private schools that provide religious instruction. Maine offers this aid in districts without their own public secondary schools, but it excludes "sectarian" schools.

Vote

The case is still pending, and no oral argument is scheduled yet. The main fight is whether Maine may offer generally available school aid but exclude schools because they provide religious instruction.

Impact

The answer could decide whether a family in a rural Maine district can use state aid at a religious high school. It could also shape how other states design school-aid programs that include private school options.

What's next

Watch for the Court to schedule oral argument or make another calendar move. No decision window is available yet.

What is the core fight in Carson v. Makin?

It asks whether Maine can give tuition aid to families without local public secondary schools while excluding schools that provide religious instruction.

Who could feel the effects of this case in real life?

Families in Maine towns without public secondary schools could gain or lose the option to use state aid at religious schools.

What should people watch for next in Carson v. Makin?

The next big step is oral argument scheduling or another order from the Court that shows how quickly the case is moving.

Decision

Decision record

What the Court decided

The Court is being asked whether a state can fund private schooling choices while denying families the option of religious schools.

Impact

The answer could decide whether a family in a rural Maine district can use state aid at a religious high school. It could also shape how other states design school-aid programs that include private school options.

Not official Court text.

Opinion documents

Timing

Decided June 21, 2022

The Court released its decision on June 21, 2022 without hearing oral argument.