Skip to main content

No. 23-5038October Term 2023Decided Apr 15, 2024

Docket 23-5038October Term 2023 (2023–2024)

Michaels v. Davis

This capital case involves a challenge to a lower court's determination that the erroneous admission of an illegally obtained confession was harmless error during the penalty phase of the trial.

Case status

Current stage
Decided
Latest event
Decision released Apr 15, 2024
Case Accepted
Arguments
Decision ReleasedApr 15, 2024
What it's about

This capital case involves a challenge to a lower court's determination that the erroneous admission of an illegally obtained confession was harmless error during the penalty phase of the trial. The petitioner argues that the reviewing court failed to properly evaluate objective factors, such as jury communications and lengthy deliberations, when deciding if the error affected the jury's verdict.

Question presented

Whether the lower court's determination that the erroneous admission of an illegally obtained confession was harmless error during the penalty phase of the trial was proper, and whether the reviewing court failed to properly evaluate objective factors, such as jury communications and lengthy deliberations, when deciding if the error affected the jury's verdict?

Case path

United States Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit / Decision released Apr 15, 2024

Area

Decided Supreme Court case